We are a large wholesale lender. I am a senior underwriter. Every week, we get requests from our broker partners to have properties reappraised. When the appraisal comes back below what they need, they complain to the Account Executives, who then request that we ask for an appraisal re-evaluation.
Whether we use an AMC or a staff appraiser, we go through a set of procedures to request a second appraisal review to get a valuation closer to the broker’s expectations. It doesn’t always work out, but sometimes we find deficiencies in the original appraisal report, which, if adjusted for, can change the valuation.
We have a Reconsideration of Value policy and procedure for this process. Our problem is that the new compliance officer is taking the position that this process interferes with appraisal independence. I would like to know if appraisal independence is compromised by requesting a re-evaluation.
Does Reconsideration of Value compromise appraisal independence?
Are there procedures we can implement to avoid compromising appraisal independence?
