The company instructed Davis to use whatever means he thought necessary to run off the sheepherders. This included shooting up sheep camps. Unfortunately, during one of his forays, he accidentally shot a herder named Bill Tolman.
Fearing that Tolman might die - and he would be hung - Davis fled south into Nevada to hide. While wandering around Northern Nevada, Davis often boasted about his shooting prowess and claimed he was paid $150 per month to kill sheepherders.
In 1896, Davis reappeared in southern Idaho, again working for Sparks-Harrell (Tolman, fortunately, did not die). In February, two other herders, John Wilson and Daniel Cummings, were found dead in their camp in the Shoshone basin area near Twin Falls, Idaho.
Davis was an immediate suspect since he was known to have been in the area at the time of the shootings, and he had bragged so much about killing sheepherders. Once again, he headed south, this time hoping to escape to Mexico.
However, while in Arizona, Davis became embroiled in a separate shooting incident and was arrested. While sitting in a territorial prison, he was extradited to Idaho, where he was put on trial for murder and convicted of killing the two sheep men. Following a sensational trial that was prominently featured in regional newspapers, Davis was sentenced to be hanged on June 4, 1897.
But Davisā luck held out. Days before he was to be hung, two other men confessed to the killings. They cast doubt on Davisā guilt. Following several years of appeals, he was finally pardoned on Dec. 17, 1902.
Diamondfield Jack had spent nearly seven years in prison, for a crime of which he was almost certainly innocent.
If leaving Nevada years earlier was a poor decision, returning to it proved an inspired move. Jackās release coincided with the recent discovery of gold and silver and he gravitated to the aptly-named new town of Goldfield. The marriage between the boomtown and the colorful ex-convict was nothing less than inspired.
Although physically a small man, both his reputation and his larger-than-life personality made him a perfect fit for the wide-open community. He had lost none of his bravado; a photograph of the period shows him holding a shotgun in his right hand, while his left is drawing a Colt revolver, with a second pistol in his belt.
|