SHARE:  
HSPP/IRB Bulletin
June 30, 2022
Hot Off the Press
With Sincere Appreciation to Our Retiring Board Members

As your time on the Rutgers Human Subject Protection Program draws to a close, we wanted to express our sincere gratitude for your service. HSPP service is one of the toughest volunteer roles at an Academic Medical Center.  Thank you for your contributions and the expertise you brought to our deliberations. 

Cheryl Forst, RN, BSN, CCRP 2004-2022
Human Subjects Protection Program
18 years of service to the HSPP



Pending Implementation of a Human Subjects Training Program known as CIRTification

The Rutgers Human Subjects Protection Program (HSPP) IRB will begin offering an educational training alternative option for research involving community partners; the alternative option is known as CIRTification. The rollout of CIRTification at Rutgers will begin soon.   
 
What is CIRTification? The CIRTification is a program developed by Dr. Emily Anderson at the Center of Clinical and Translational Sciences (the University of Illinois at Chicago) to provide the core research ethics in lay language CIRTification is a free, web-based human research protections training program tailored specifically to the needs and roles of community research partners. The program is offered in English and in Spanish. The CIRTification program is a training alternative for individuals in community organizations, with limited understanding of conducting human research and protecting potential research participants. This option provides training that focuses on establishing the skills in community partners to conduct human subject research effectively and safely in their communities.   
 
 
Who can take CIRTification? The CIRTification program is only for individuals from community organizations who are working with Rutgers faculty, staff, or students on human subjects research.  
  
Who cannot take CIRTification? CIRTification training will not be available to Rutgers faculty, staff, and students; instead Rutgers faculty, staff and students are required to complete the Rutgers CITI training. For more information about CITI training requirements of Rutgers faculty, staff, and students engaged in human subjects research, please see:https://research.rutgers.edu/researcher-support/research-compliance/research-integrity/collaborative-institutional-training.   
 
 
Any other Information? The community-based partners cannot have access to Protected Health Information (PHI) associated with or derived from a healthcare service event (I.e., from treatment, payment, operations or from medical records). Community-based partners cannot be associated with an institution that has its own Human Subjects Training requirements. More information about CIRTification is coming soon. 


  Pre-Review Process Update

The Pre-Review SOP's (copied below) have been updated to reflect the revised Pre-Review Team effective immediately. 

To begin the Pre-Review process, please upload the relevant documents as WORD documents in Rutgers OneDrive or Rutgers Box (i.e., only one of these folders needs to be used) to allow the pre-review team to make tracked changes/comments See Rutgers OneDrive Instructions below 

Share the folder with the pre-review team members listed below:  
 
Jason Lin, Senior Research Project Manager, jcl268@research.rutgers.edu 
Rebecca Chen, ClinicalTrials.Gov, chennr@research.rutgers.edu 
Angela Cartmell-McGlyn, Sr IRB Manager, ac2200@research.rutgers.edu 
Claribel Vega, Sr. Reliance Manager, vegacl@research.rutgers.edu 
Carlotta Rodriguez, Executive Director HSPP, rodrigcm@research.rutgers.edu  
Cheryl Kennedy, IRB Chair, kennedy@njms.rutgers.edu  
Irbprereview@research.rutgers.edu 
 
This Pre-Review should be done simultaneously as you work on the following:  
eIRB application (please do not submit the application or upload the documents until they have been pre-reviewed by the pre-review team and then finalized by you).  

If your research will be conducted on Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital (RWJUH) New Brunswick property or involve RWJUH New Brunswick patients, their data or biospecimens, then you must submit an application to the RWJUH Research Utilization Group (RUG).  

To access the RUG form, please visit our website under 'Performance Site Approval Forms': https://research.rutgers.edu/researcher-support/research-compliance/human-subjects-protection-program-toolkit .  

If your research is conducted on University Hospital (UH) property or involve University Hospital patients, their data or biospecimens you must submit a UH Registration and Research Plan through the Office of Clinical Research Administration. 

Please refer to our website at https://research.rutgers.edu/researcher-support/research-compliance/human-subjects-protection-program-toolkit and view instructions under ‘Performance Site Approval Forms’ then under University Hospital.  

eCOI disclosures/CITI for the Principal Investigator and all research personnel 

eCOI - Please click the ‘Create financial disclosure certification in eCOI’ in the eIRB study workspace and select all study personnel. 

Any other required approvals applicable to your protocol such as Biosafety, Radiation Safety, Scientific Review Board, University Behavioral Health Care signoff, etc.  

Any contracts or agreements applicable to your protocol such as Clinical Trial Agreements, Data Use Agreements  

IRB Reliance Agreements, to accept another IRBs approval or for Rutgers to serve as the IRB of record for other sites involved in your research. For information regarding IRB Reliance Agreements please contact the IRB Reliance Administrator: IRBRelianceAdmin@research.rutgers.edu 
 
*Options for studies recommended for Pre-Review after submission in eIRB: 

Option 1:  
Withdraw the study in eIRB. 
Upload the protocol and relevant documents to Rutgers OneDrive or Rutgers Box and share with the Pre-Review Team listed below.  
Once you are notified the Pre-Review is complete, address the comments/suggestions as you deem appropriate. 
The PI creates and submits a new application in eIRB and submits for IRB review. 

Option 2:  
Allow the study/modification to proceed through the regular IRB process as submitted without pre-review 
 
II. Pre-Review Completed  
We will notify you via email once the pre-review is completed. Please keep in mind that this courtesy pre-review is intended to help expedite the approval process and the comments are recommendations - individual IRB members (who are faculty familiar with a variety of research) may have additional comments during the review process, after you submit your protocol through eIRB.  

Log into Rutgers OneDrive or Box to review the comments and address as you deem appropriate.  

When your revisions are complete upload the final versions in eIRB before submitting your application.  
For research related questions please email irboffice@research.rutgers.edu  
 
III. Instructions for Uploading to OneDrive 
Navigate to connect.rutgers.edu. Log in using your Rutgers NetID and password. 

If you are already logged into your Rutgers e-mail it will bring you to your email home screen. If you haven’t logged in yet it will direct, you to log in  

From your e-mail home screen via connect.rutgers.edu click on the icon in the top left corner (it is a box made up of 9 dots)  

Click on “OneDrive.”  

Click on the tab “New” (there is a plus sign next to it) and select “folder.”  

Create a name for the folder using the following notation: PI FULL NAME AND SHORT TITLE.  
Example: “John Doe Perceptions of Masks.” (Please do not simply label it as “IRB” or a similar generic title.)  

Click on the folder created.  

Click on the tab “Upload” and select the WORD documents you would like to upload.  

Return to the previous screen that has the Folder you created.  

Highlight the folder you created and click on the arrow icon (to the right of the folder name) to “share” 

Select the Pre-Review Team members for your campus (listed above) to share the file with them by entering their e-mail addresses. You may also enter an optional message to the team. Once you have entered everyone you want to share the file with click on send.  

The Pre-Review Team will automatically receive an email notification and link to the file 
 
IV. Instructions for Uploading to Rutgers BOX 
  
Link to the BOX website instructions 
 
 
 
IRB Member Spotlight

Daniella Colombo

Daniella Colombo, is a third-year medical student at Rutgers New Jersey Medical School. She earned a bachelor’s degree in Psychology from Amherst College. Ms. Colombo entered medical school with an interest in exploring issues of ethics. Becoming a member of the IRB was a great opportunity to get hands-on exposure.  
  
As a recent addition to the IRB, joining in early 2022, Ms. Colombo has increased her knowledge base with regard to research and research ethics. Ms. Colombo reports to really enjoy learning more about the diversity in design of various types of research studies that all succeed in protecting the privacy and welfare of participants. Having an active role in the review of IRB applications has given her great experience in preparation for her own research projects. The IRB is thrilled to have Ms. Colombo on the IRB and looks forward to working with her in the years to come. 


Michael (Myungkook) Joo, PhD 

Dr. Michael (Myungkook) Joo, PhD, is an Associate Professor in the School of Social Work at the Rutgers University. Dr. Joo earned his Master’s in Social Work (MSW) from the School of Social Work at the University of South Carolina and his PhD from the Brown School of Social Work at Washington University in St. Louis. Dr. Joo’s research interests are in early childhood development, analyses of policies and programs designed to help low-income children, and effects of poverty and economic inequality on children's outcomes.

Dr. Joo joined the Rutgers University IRB in the spring of 2018 at the suggestion of a colleague who had served on the IRB for ten years. Since joining the IRB, Dr. Joo has enjoyed learning about the unique and fascinating studies going on in the Rutgers research community. The IRB benefits greatly from Dr. Joo’s knowledge of children, which are considered a vulnerable population, as well as Dr. Joo’s experience with policy and program analysis. 


Kristen Krause, PhD

Dr. Kristen Krause, PhD, is an Instructor in the Department of Urban-Global Public Health and the Deputy Director of the Center for Health, Identity, Behavior and Prevention Studies (CHIBPS) at the Rutgers School of Public Health. Dr. Krause earned her Master of Public Health (MPH) from the Global Institute of Public Health at New York University and her PhD from Rutgers School of Public Health. Dr. Joo’s research interests are in HIV/AIDS, aging, resilience, and broader LGBTQ health disparities. 

Dr. Krause joined the Rutgers University IRB in 2021. Her inspiration was to learn about what other researchers at Rutgers are studying and discover ways to improve inclusivity and accessibility for underrepresented communities in research spaces. Dr. Krause enjoys helping other researchers improve their research studies, even if it's something as simple as re-wording a phrase on a flyer or as complex as creating a data integrity plan to help with Bot detection. She is flexible in her ability to learn new things and still support the research that is conducted at Rutgers. Although a recent addition to the IRB, Dr. Krause has already provided beneficial knowledge to the IRB based on her career, research, and educational experience. 



New Board Members


Melinda Jenkins, PhD, FNP (she/herhas joined the Rutgers IRB as an expedited reviewer. Dr. Jenkins is an experienced primary care nurse practitioner and administrator with exceptional credentials in clinical and consumer informatics, Dr. Melinda Jenkins serves as an Associate Professor, Clinical Scholar track, and Informatics Program Specialty Director, in the Division of Advanced Nursing Practice at the Rutgers School of Nursing. For five years at the National Institutes of Health (NIH), Center for Scientific Review, Dr. Jenkins managed regular meetings for scientific merit peer review of multidisciplinary clinical informatics research and related small business applications. Her research expertise is in Clinical and consumer informatics, data quality, primary care, access to care, and quality of care. We welcome Dr. Jenkins onto the IRB and look forward to working with her. 


Interested in Becoming an IRB Member
Do you (or someone you know) have an interest in biomedical or social science research? Or do you know someone from the community that might be interested in serving as a community member on the Rutgers IRB? Would you (or they) like to be involved with protecting the rights, safety, and welfare of individuals who volunteer to participate in research?

Please read more information online about IRB Membership or by contacting our Training and Communications Manager, Michelle Watkinson, CIP.


Interested in Being a Featured Board Member in a Future Issue of this Bulletin?
Share your background, interests, and area(s) of expertise by being a featured board member in an upcoming issue of the HSPP/IRB Bulletin

Please contact Claribel Vega @ claribel.vega@rutgers.edu or Angela Cartmell-McGlynn if interested.

HSPP Website

Website Revisions


  • Updated information on the Pre-Review Service page 
  • Updated Staff Directory to include new hires. 
  • Revised information on the Single IRB page under About Reliance Agreements to update the Procedures for Collaborating with Other Institutions 

 

AAHRPP Accreditation Updates
The Rutgers University is looking forward to the AAHRPP on-site visit scheduled for this upcoming summer for the evaluation of the HSPP/IRB program!

ClinicalTrials.gov News

FDA Issues 4th Notice of Noncompliance for ClinicalTrials.gov Violations

On April 15, 2022, FDA issued a Notice of Noncompliance to a responsible party (Ocugen) for failing to submit required results data to ClinicalTrials.gov.

This is the fourth Notice that FDA has issued for ClinicalTrials.gov violations. FDA has issued over 60 pre-notices since January 2020. Although pre-notices are not routinely made public by FDA, Universities Allied for Essential Medicine, a trial transparency advocacy organization, obtained and published many of these notices via a Freedom of Information Act request in November 2021.

In addition to the issuing of a Notice of Noncompliance, which remains permanently public, FDA is authorized to seek civil money penalties of up to $10,000 per day, injunction, and even criminal prosecution of the responsible party for failure to submit required information to ClinicalTrials.gov.

FDA is ramping up enforcement, and the risk for noncompliance is increasing. If you have a record that is out of compliance (e.g., for late or missing results information), or if you need to register or update a record on ClinicalTrials.gov, contact Rutgers ClinicalTrials.gov Support at rutgersctgsupport@research.rutgers.edu for help.

Single IRB News

Status Report for “Administrative Review” submissions


Effective June 1, 2022, to reduce administrative burden of the investigators and research community, request for continuing review of “Administrative Review” submissions will be replaced by “Status Report”. For submissions approved as “Administrative Review”, the investigators will now submit a “status report” instead of “continuing review” request along with the renewed IRB approval from the IRB of record.  

When the eIRB continuation reminder is received, please sign into your eIRB initial workspace and create a Continuing Report. For renewal, please select “Status Report” in section 1.0 Study Status as the type of report as shown in the screen shot below.  
The eIRB system will populate an abbreviated continuation application that requires information regarding the status of your research. If there are any questions, please contact us via IRBOffice@research.rutgers.edu

 
Pre-Consultation for Multi-Site or Collaborative Study


It is highly recommended that a Rutgers Principal Investigator contact the Rutgers Institutional Review Board (IRB) to discuss the options available for IRB review to process a multi-site or collaborative study where Rutgers will either be the lead or participating site.

Please contact the IRB Reliance Administrator at irbrelianceadmin@research.rutgers.edu to schedule a pre-consultation meeting.
Education and Training Opportunities
time_2_learn_vector.jpg

eIRB Virtual Training Workshops Sessions will include a step-by-step tutorial on the electronic submission system, eIRB and Q&A.

These workshops are open to Rutgers faculty, staff, and/or students regardless of campus location or specific Rutgers IRB of Record.

Upcoming eIRB Workshops (all dates available online):   

  • Wednesday, July 13, 2022 at 2:30 pm  
  • Thursday, July 21, 2022 at 11:30 am  
  • Wednesday, July 26, 2022 at 2:30 pm  
  • Wednesday, August 3, 2022 at 11:30 am 
  • Tuesday, August 9, 2022 at 11:30 am 
  • Wednesday, September 7, 2022 at 11:30 am 
  • Wednesday, September 14, 2022 at 2:30 pm 



Education Items
 
This article provides suggesting now how to efficiently improve oversight of research using medical and behavioral apps in research, "When Change is Significant-The App Update Problem: Research Ethics Confronts the Growing Use of Apps". 

With a significant increase in the use of apps in medical and behavioral research, best practice standards are needed for ethics oversight of app updates. A good starting point is to distinguish between minor updates (e.g., a change in screen color), updates that require prompt notification (e.g., requests for additional information from users), and significant changes (e.g., affecting privacy) that may require a re-review by an institutional review board, concludes a new article in Ethics & Human ResearchRead the article.  
    
The three articles below discuss enrollment challenges including a lack of diversity in clinical research and lack of diversity among researchers. These articles highlightt the importance of the Belmont Report's Ethical Principle of Justice (which is meant to promote equitable representation in research in terms of fairly distributing the risks and benefits of research):  


Stay Tuned!
In the works: 

  • “How to Write an IRB Review” Guidance for IRB Members.
  • General IRB Member Survey
  • ​Customer Service Satisfaction Surveys for Website & Email Interactions.
  • Implementation of a Human Subjects Training Program known as CIRTification