L’chatchila, the chazan must daven a quiet Shemoneh Esrei before he says Chazoras Hashatz to make sure that he is fluent in the tefillah before the repetition. Nonetheless, if he arrives late and must serve as chazan (e.g. he is an avel or he is the only person that can be the chazan), he should just say Chazoras Hashatz and he will be yotzei his personal obligation as well as the obligation of Chazoras Hashatz. If it is close to zman tefillah and there is not enough time for both the quiet Shemoneh Esrei and Chazoras Hashatz, the chazan should recite the first three brochos – including Kedushah – aloud, while the tzibur davens along with him. After Hakel Hakodosh, everyone continues the Shemoneh Esrei quietly. Some congregations choose this option l’chatchilah for Mincha. This is known as the “short Mincha”. The poskim explain this practice as follows: Chazoras Hashatz was originally instituted for congregations which had members who could not daven themselves. Therefore, in batei medrash where all the members were always well educated, Chazoros Hashatz was never instituted for Mincha.
ס"ב ס"ק ד'-ט' ביאורים ומוספים דרשו 13
|