Informal Institute for National Security Thinkers and Practitioners

On December 7, 1941, Japanese planes attacked the United States Naval Base at Pearl Harbor, Hawaii Territory, killing more than 2,300 Americans. The U.S.S. Arizona was completely destroyed and the U.S.S. Oklahoma capsized.


Quotes of the Day:


“Yesterday, December 7, 1941 — a date which will live in infamy — the United States of America was suddenly and deliberately attacked by naval and air forces of the Empire of Japan.” 
– Franklin D. Roosevelt on the morning after the Pearl Harbor attack

“Before we’re through with them, the Japanese language will be spoken only in Hell.” 
– Vice Admiral William F. “Bull” Halsey, spoken from his flagship Enterprise upon returning to Pearl Harbor and seeing the wreckage that included his scout aircraft.

“I fear all we have done is to awaken a sleeping giant and fill him with a terrible resolve.” 
– attributed to Japanese Admiral Isoroku Yamamoto

1. Security advisors of S. Korea, U.S., Japan to discuss 'robust' agenda of regional security issues: White House

2. G7 leaders strongly condemn N. Korea's satellite launch, arms transfers to Russia

3. Auditor says Moon gov't neglected, covered up, distorted 2020 death of fisheries official

4. S. Korean lawyer elected as new ICC judge

5. S. Korea affirms support for UN peacekeeping missions

6. Korea National Diplomatic Academy, U.S intel bureau ink cooperation arrangement

7. NYT picks President Yoon, NewJeans among 71 'most stylish' people of 2023

8. Congresswoman redoubles calls for support to designate Nov. 22 as 'Kimchi Day'

9. Korea’s Army of Senior Citizens Ready for Battle. ‘I Don’t Remember the Rifles Being So Heavy’

10. S. Korea pushing to host trilateral summit with U.S., Japan next year

11. The 2023 War on the Rocks Holiday Reading List




1. Security advisors of S. Korea, U.S., Japan to discuss 'robust' agenda of regional security issues: White House

Here are some issues:


US-PRC competition ( Strategic Competition)

PRC support to Russia in Ukraine

nK support for Russia in Ukraine

nK support to Hamas (and other malign actors in Middle East and Africa)

PRC Pressure on ROK for NATO alignment (diplomatic and economic warfare)

NE Asia – nexus of revisionist/rogue powers (to include north Korea-Iran relations)

Way ahead with north Korea 

Continued nK satellite and other missile launches

Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership – 15 countries – No US

South China Sea and FON – US, Japan (and ROK?)

China’s OBOR/BRI (and beyond Asia)

Flashpoint- Taiwan – Japan/US plans – ROK off pen ops

COVID

US basing in the INDOPACOM 

Missile Defense and Intermediate Range Missile deployments

ROK-Japan historical issues – Trilateral relations - sustain this major line of effort INDOPACFIC Strategy

NEO – Korea, Japan, Taiwan – Afghanistan Lessons (What lessons have our adversaries learned?)

Ukraine - Impact of Putin’s War

Learning that KJU is no longer in power – how to engage?

Regime Instability and Collapse

Post-collapse and post-conflict in north Korea

Unification

Chinese intervention in Korea

COVID response throughout Asia

Provocations To Gain Political And Economic Concessions

NK Attack – Execution Of The nK Campaign Plan To Unify The Peninsula By Force

Civil War / Chaos / Anarchy

Refugee Crisis

Humanitarian Assistance / Disaster Relief

WMD, Loss Of Control – Seize And Secure Operations

Resistance To Foreign Intervention (E.G., Insurgency)

How To Handle The nKPA During Regime Collapse Short Of War

Taiwan Or Korea? Both? Sequential Or Simultaneous?

U.S. Defense Of Taiwan – Japan Support (Territory Threatened)

ROK, With Alliance, Must Continue To Deter North Korea.

Challenge: Dual Apportioned U.S. Forces.


Sir Lawrence Freedman: “Deterrence Works; Until It Doesn’t”

Security advisors of S. Korea, U.S., Japan to discuss 'robust' agenda of regional security issues: White House | Yonhap News Agency

en.yna.co.kr · by Song Sang-ho · December 7, 2023

By Song Sang-ho

WASHINGTON, Dec. 6 (Yonhap) -- National security advisors of South Korea, the United States and Japan are expected to discuss a "robust" agenda of regional security issues and trilateral cooperation at their talks in Seoul this week, a White House official said Wednesday.

John Kirby, National Security Council coordinator for strategic communications, made the remarks as South Korea's National Security Adviser Cho Tae-yong and his U.S. and Japanese counterparts, Jake Sullivan and Takeo Akiba, respectively, are set to meet on Saturday.

The meeting comes as the three countries are stepping up cooperation amid North Korea's persistent military threats, China's growing assertiveness and Russia's protracted war in Ukraine.

"I think you can expect a robust agenda of discussions of regional issues of mutual concern, particularly in the security environment," Kirby told a press briefing.

"I know that Jake is looking forward to having discussions with both of those leaders about how we can build on the Camp David agreement and really try to improve our trilateral cooperation as well as bilateral cooperation between the Republic of Korea and Japan," he added.

Kirby was referring to the agreement from the Camp David summit in August -- the first standalone trilateral summit among Seoul, Washington and Tokyo.

The summit between South Korean President Yoon Suk Yeol and his U.S. and Japanese counterparts, Joe Biden and Fumio Kishida, produced a series of landmark agreements, including their "commitment to consult" each other in case of a common threat.

The three countries held their last three-way meeting among national security advisors in Tokyo in June.


sshluck@yna.co.kr

(END)

en.yna.co.kr · by Song Sang-ho · December 7, 2023


2. G7 leaders strongly condemn N. Korea's satellite launch, arms transfers to Russia


G7 leaders strongly condemn N. Korea's satellite launch, arms transfers to Russia | Yonhap News Agency

en.yna.co.kr · by Song Sang-ho · December 7, 2023

By Song Sang-ho

WASHINGTON, Dec. 6 (Yonhap) -- The leaders of the Group of Seven (G7) countries "strongly" condemned North Korea's recent spy satellite launch and its arms transfers to Russia on Wednesday, stressing the moves directly contravene U.N. Security Council (UNSC) resolutions.

The leaders of the United States, Britain, France, Germany, Canada, Italy and Japan issued a statement on a range of global issues, including Russia's war in Ukraine and the war between Israel and the Hamas militant group, after they met virtually.

"We strongly condemn continued ballistic missile launches, the recent launch using ballistic missile technology conducted on November 21, 2023, and arms transfers from North Korea to Russia, which directly violate relevant UNSCRs," the statement reads.

Under the UNSC resolutions, the North is banned from conducting any launch using ballistic missile technology and engaging in any arms trade.

G7 leaders also reiterated their call for the "complete, verifiable and irreversible" dismantlement of all of North Korea's weapons of mass destruction and ballistic missiles.

They, in addition, urged Pyongyang to respect human rights, facilitate access for international humanitarian organizations and resolve the abductions issue immediately.

To curtail Russia's revenue that can be used for its war efforts, G7 leaders said they will introduce restrictions on non-industrial diamonds mined, processed or produced in Russia by Jan. 1, according to the statement.

The move is to be followed by further phased restrictions on the imports of Russian diamonds processed in third countries, targeting March 1 as the day for implementation, it added.

On the war between Israel and Hamas, the leaders urged the immediate release of all remaining hostages, held by the militant group, without preconditions.

"At the same time, more urgent action is needed to address the deteriorating humanitarian crisis in Gaza and minimize civilian casualties," they said. "We support and encourage further humanitarian pauses to enable this."


A new type of Chollima-1 rocket carrying a reconnaissance satellite called the Malligyong-1 lifts off from the launching pad at the Sohae satellite launch site in Tongchang-ri, northwestern North Korea, at 10:42 p.m. on Nov. 21, 2023, in this file photo released the next day by the North's official Korean Central News Agency. (For Use Only in the Republic of Korea. No Redistribution) (Yonhap)

sshluck@yna.co.kr

(END)

en.yna.co.kr · by Song Sang-ho · December 7, 2023









3. Auditor says Moon gov't neglected, covered up, distorted 2020 death of fisheries official


A disgraceful incident.


Auditor says Moon gov't neglected, covered up, distorted 2020 death of fisheries official | Yonhap News Agency

en.yna.co.kr · by Yoo Cheong-mo · December 7, 2023

SEOUL, Dec. 7 (Yonhap) -- The state audit agency on Thursday announced the final results of its inspection into the 2020 death of a South Korean fisheries official at the hands of North Korea, concluding that the then Moon Jae-in government did little to save him and covered up and distorted facts related to the case.

The Board of Audit and Inspection (BAI) reached the conclusion after its yearlong inspection into the preceding Moon government's handling of the killing of the fisheries official, Lee Dae-jun, by the North's military near the inter-Korean maritime border in the Yellow Sea on Sept. 22, 2020.

The BAI said the Moon government responded negligently and took no action before Lee's death and covered up the incident after the North murdered the official and burned his body, jumping to the conclusion that he attempted to defect to the North.


The Board of Audit and Inspection (Yonhap)

The audit agency demanded that 13 people involved in illegal and unfair practices be disciplined or cautioned and records be left in their personnel data to disadvantage them in their possible reemployment in public office. It also asked the related public organizations to take caution.

The 13 people reportedly included former Defense Minister Suh Wook and former Coast Guard Commissioner General Kim Hong-hee. The BAI unveiled its final audit results in a press release on the basis of its interim conclusion, disclosed in October last year, but did not make public the original text for national security reasons.

The state auditor last year requested the prosecution investigate 20 people, including the former defense minister, former National Security Adviser Suh Hoon and former National Intelligence Service (NIS) chief Park Jie-won, and court trials are currently under way.

According to the BAI finding, all the relevant agencies, such as the presidential National Security Office (NSO), the Coast Guard, the unification and defense ministries, and the NIS virtually sat idle and did not take any action even before Lee's death.

The NSO, the de facto national crisis management control tower, received a report from the Joint Chiefs of Staff (JCS) that the missing fisheries official was discovered in North Korean waters on the afternoon of Sept. 22, 2020, but did not share the report with the unification ministry and other agencies, let alone hold an initial situation assessment meeting.

Suh Hoon, then chief of the NSO, left work early, and a senior NSO official in charge of national crisis management also left work at 7:30 p.m., even though the situation was not over.

The Coast Guard received a report from the NSO around 6 p.m. but did not try to obtain additional information and request necessary cooperation from the defense ministry. A senior unification ministry official was notified by the NIS of the situation but failed to report it to the minister or vice minister.

The defense ministry received a report from the JCS but did not review the need to send a message to North Korea or possible measures from the military. Moreover, the ministry did not make any recommendations to the NSO.

After Lee was shot to death and burned, the relevant organizations deleted and distorted data to cover up the facts and deliberately highlighted his possible attempt to defect to the North.

At a meeting of relevant ministers held at 1 a.m. on Sept. 23, the NSO issued guidelines for maintaining security regarding the incineration of Lee's body, and the defense ministry ordered the JCS to delete the related confidential data at 2:30 a.m.

The unification ministry falsely told parliament and the media that it first became aware of the incident in the early morning of Sept. 23, though it was notified by the NIS on the afternoon of Sept. 22.

The Moon government also announced to the nation several times that Lee had voluntarily defected to North Korea.

ycm@yna.co.kr

(END)

en.yna.co.kr · by Yoo Cheong-mo · December 7, 2023



4. S. Korean lawyer elected as new ICC judge


Global pivotal state supporting the rules based international order.



(2nd LD) S. Korean lawyer elected as new ICC judge | Yonhap News Agency

en.yna.co.kr · by Yi Wonju · December 7, 2023

(ATTN: ADDS more info in paras 3, 5-6; CHANGES dateline)

By Song Sang-ho

WASHINGTON/NEW YORK/SEOUL, Dec. 7 (Yonhap) -- A South Korean lawyer was elected as a judge of the International Criminal Court (ICC) for the 2024-2033 period, the court's website showed Thursday, marking the third time that a South Korean national has won a seat at the court.

Paek Kee-bong, a lawyer at Kim & Chang, a South Korean law firm, was elected during a session of the Assembly of State Parties at U.N. headquarters in New York on Wednesday (local time).

He was among six newly elected ICC judges, clinching the seat by winning 83 votes out of 123.

Paek graduated from the college of law at Seoul National University in 1987 and from Columbia Law School in 1998. He earned his Ph.D. in international law from Hanyang University in 2008.

He previously worked as a state prosecutor for more than two decades. He also served as a senior prosecutorial and judicial advisor at the U.N. Office on Drugs and Crime's regional office for Southeast Asia and the Pacific in Bangkok from 2011-2014.

South Korea's foreign ministry welcomed the election of Paek, saying "South Korea has achieved the feat of advancing its judges for the fourth consecutive time since the establishment of the ICC."

"With various experiences and a deep understanding of the Rome Statute, Paek is expected to play a significant role in improving the efficiency of trials by (addressing issues of) serious crimes and victim relief dealt with by the ICC, as well as utilizing advanced IT technology," the ministry said in a press release.


This photo from the homepage of the Kim & Chang law firm shows Paek Kee-bong, a lawyer at the firm. (PHOTO NOT FOR SALE) (Yonhap)

Currently, Chung Chang-ho of South Korea sits on the ICC bench with his nine-year term set to end in March next year. Song Sang-hyun, another South Korean national, served as an ICC judge from 2003-2015. From 2009-2015, Song also worked as the court president.

Headquartered at The Hague, the ICC investigates and, where warranted, tries individuals charged with grave crimes of concern to the international community -- genocide, war crimes, crimes against humanity and crimes of aggression, according to its website.

The court has a total of 18 judges who are elected by the Assembly of State Parties for a nine-year, nonrenewable term. The judges elect, from among themselves, the ICC president and two vice presidents.

It has 123 state parties, including South Korea, Japan, Britain, France, Germany and Italy.

sshluck@yna.co.kr

(END)

en.yna.co.kr · by Yi Wonju · December 7, 2023



5. S. Korea affirms support for UN peacekeeping missions


Again, the global pivotal state supporting the rules based international order.



S. Korea affirms support for UN peacekeeping missions | Yonhap News Agency

en.yna.co.kr · by Yi Wonju · December 7, 2023

SEOUL, Dec. 7 (Yonhap) -- South Korea has attended a United Nations peacekeeping ministerial forum and pledged its support for the global community's commitment to strengthen peacekeeping operations (PKO), Seoul's foreign ministry said Thursday.

The South Korean delegation led by Kweon Ki-hwan, the deputy foreign minister for multilateral and global affairs, attended the two-day "2023 UN Peacekeeping Ministerial" that kicked off Tuesday in Accra, Ghana, where over 80 member nations discussed ways to enhance PKO missions, according to the ministry.

Kweon affirmed South Korea's support for PKO missions and pledged to provide medical training to peacekeeping personnel as a follow-up to an initiative Seoul announced while hosting the 2021 forum to capitalize on new technologies and boost medical capacity, it added.

Separately, Kweon paid a courtesy call on Shirley Ayorkor Botchwey, the foreign minister of Ghana, and discussed Ghana's experiences in the U.N. Security Council (UNSC) as a nonpermanent member in 2022-2023.

The meeting came as South Korea prepares to assume a two-year term as a nonpermanent UNSC member in 2024-25.


Kweon Ki-hwan, the deputy foreign minister for multilateral and global affairs, speaks during a session of the 2023 UN Peacekeeping Ministerial, in Accra, Ghana, on Dec. 5-6, 2023, in this photo provided by Seoul's foreign ministry on Dec. 7. (PHOTO NOT FOR SALE) (Yonhap)

julesyi@yna.co.kr

(END)

en.yna.co.kr · by Yi Wonju · December 7, 2023


6. Korea National Diplomatic Academy, U.S intel bureau ink cooperation arrangement


Korea National Diplomatic Academy, U.S intel bureau ink cooperation arrangement | Yonhap News Agency

en.yna.co.kr · by Song Sang-ho · December 7, 2023

By Song Sang-ho

WASHINGTON, Dec. 6 (Yonhap) -- The Korea National Diplomatic Academy and the U.S. State Department's Bureau of Intelligence and Research signed an arrangement Wednesday to hold regular "strategic dialogue" and institutionalize bilateral cooperation, the academy said.

Park Cheol-hee, chancellor of the foreign ministry-affiliated academy, and Brett Holmgren, assistant secretary of state for intelligence and research signed the terms of reference (TOR) during Park's visit to the bureau in Washington.

"Through the TOR, the two institutions agree to hold regular strategic dialogue at least once every year to share views and perspectives on matters of strategic interest, including Indo-Pacific and global strategies as well as the Korean Peninsula issues," the academy said in a press release.

The academy expects that the TOR will help enhance its diplomatic research capabilities and contribute to the development of the foreign ministry's capabilities for diplomatic information analysis and policy planning, according to the release.


Park Cheol-hee (L), chancellor of the Korea National Diplomatic Academy, and Brett Holmgren, U.S. assistant secretary of state for intelligence and research, pose for a photo after signing an arrangement on bilateral cooperation in Washington on Dec. 6, 2023 in this photo released by the academy. (PHOTO NOT FOR SALE) (Yonhap)

sshluck@yna.co.kr

(END)

en.yna.co.kr · by Song Sang-ho · December 7, 2023


7. NYT picks President Yoon, NewJeans among 71 'most stylish' people of 2023



Korean soft power. Including President Yoon. American Pie did it for him.


NYT picks President Yoon, NewJeans among 71 'most stylish' people of 2023 | Yonhap News Agency

en.yna.co.kr · by Song Sang-ho · December 7, 2023

By Song Sang-ho

WASHINGTON, Dec. 6 (Yonhap) -- The New York Times has chosen South Korean President Yoon Suk Yeol and rookie K-pop girl group NewJeans as part of its 71 "most stylish" people of 2023, it said Wednesday.

The U.S. daily unveiled this year's list of prominent figures, including singer Beyonce, rapper Doja Cat, actress Gwyneth Paltrow and even the artificial intelligence-generated image of Pope Francis.

In an article on the list, the daily posted a photo of Yoon singing Don McLean's best-known song, American Pie, at a dinner during his state visit to the United States for a summit with U.S. President Joe Biden in April.

"His pitch-perfect performance of 'American Pie' at the White House was worthy of 'American Idol,'" the daily said.


This photo distributed by Reuters shows U.S. President Joe Biden shouting while President Yoon Suk Yeol sings during a state dinner at the White House on April 26, 2023 (Yonhap)

Yoon's rendition of American Pie went viral online. During the state dinner, Yoon received a standing ovation and loud applause from the audience. Biden presented him with a guitar signed by Don McLean on behalf of the musician, who could not attend the dinner.

On the K-pop girl group, the newspaper highlighted their accomplishments.

"With a sound inspired by late '90s and early 2000s R&B, the bunny-ears-wearing members of NewJeans climbed to the top of Billboard charts and earned various distinctions -- including being the first female K-pop act to play Lollapalooza," it said.

In August, the K-pop quintet delivered a high-profile performance at Lollapalooza Chicago, one of the major music festivals in the U.S. It performed a dynamic set of 12 songs, treating the over 70,000 spectators to an electrifying 45-minute live show.


South Korean girl group NewJeans performs during the Lollapalooza Chicago at the Grand Park in Chicago, Illinois, in August 2023 in this photo provided by its agency, ADOR. (PHOTO NOT FOR SALE) (Yonhap)

sshluck@yna.co.kr

(END)


en.yna.co.kr · by Song Sang-ho · December 7, 2023

8. Congresswoman redoubles calls for support to designate Nov. 22 as 'Kimchi Day'


(LEAD) Congresswoman redoubles calls for support to designate Nov. 22 as 'Kimchi Day' | Yonhap News Agency

en.yna.co.kr · by Song Sang-ho · December 7, 2023

(ATTN: CHANGES headline; RECASTS 2nd para; ADDS more info, remarks in paras 8-10)

By Song Sang-ho

WASHINGTON, Dec. 6 (Yonhap) -- A U.S. congresswoman renewed calls Wednesday for support to designate Nov. 22 as "Kimchi Day," named after a Korean traditional side dish, stressing that kimchi has now become a "culinary icon" reflective of South Korea's rising cultural influence.

Rep. Young Kim (R-CA), a Korean American lawmaker, made the call during a House session as she has submitted a resolution on the fermented dish with backing from more than a dozen other lawmakers.

"I rise in support of Kimchi Day. Kimchi is a staple Korean 'banchan' or side dish consisting of fermented cabbage or other vegetables," Kim said.

"What was once limited to Korean families' tables is now a culinary icon that reflects the growing Korean cultural influence in the United States since the first Korean immigrants arrived more than a century ago," she added.


Rep. Young Kim (R-CA) speaks during a House session in Washington on Dec. 6, 2023, in this photo captured from the livestream of the session on the House website. (PHOTO NOT FOR SALE) (Yonhap)

She also mentioned four Korean-American lawmakers, including Reps. Andy Kim and Michelle Steel, as she appreciated their role in introducing the resolution on Kimchi Day.

"We're very proud to have four Korean Americans serving in Congress," she said. "They have been instrumental in working with me in a bipartisan way to introduce this Korean Kimchi Day resolution to make Nov. 22 as Kimchi Day."

She ended her speech with a sentence in Korean that called on people to love kimchi.

Later in the day, an event was held on Capitol Hill to promote kimchi.

At the event, Kim said kimchi is not only one of the most loved side dishes for Koreans but also carries "deep historical and cultural significance."

"I hope that more people will grow aware of our Korean food, kimchi especially, and appreciate the significance and historical origins of kimchi," she said.

A Korean group dedicated to promoting kimchi has declared Nov. 22 as Kimchi Day. Since 2020, Korea has observed the day as a statutory anniversary.

According to Korea Agro-Fisheries and Food Trade Corp., South Korea's exports of kimchi products to the U.S. last year were tallied at US$29 million. As of October, kimchi exports to the U.S. this year were recorded at $33 million.

sshluck@yna.co.kr

(END)

en.yna.co.kr · by Song Sang-ho · December 7, 2023



9. Korea’s Army of Senior Citizens Ready for Battle. ‘I Don’t Remember the Rifles Being So Heavy’


True Korean patriots willing to defend their country.


As an aside many of us have written that the ROK Army really need s to upgrade its reserve force program and bring it to a higher standard at least for those between the ages of 15 and 40 - Ioneweekend a month and two weeks in the summer would be a good model so that they do not forget how heavy rifles are.


Excerpts:


In light of the country’s population crisis, we will prepare ourselves so that we may one day be of service in the nation’s military reserves.
A gimmick this was not. After taking out personal injury insurance policies for its members, the group had asked the military for the full package: two nights in the barracks and live-fire shooting drills.
“I’m not interested in training just for show,” said 63-year-old Kim Seok-beom, who recently retired from the railroad industry. “I want real-life applicability.”
But both of these requests had been denied, and the military had limited the number of participants to 20.
Lt. Col. Hwang’s team had arranged for two exercises instead: urban warfare and marksmanship, in the center’s virtual reality shooting range.
In the urban warfare exercise, two teams — Team Yellow and Team Blue — would battle for control of a mock city street, using rifles that shot digital bullets. The body armor, outfitted with laser sensors, would beep when its wearer was shot.
The combat simulation is a standard part of actual reserves training, designed to teach the kind of team-based tactics required in South Korea’s densely populated urban areas.


Korea’s Army of Senior Citizens Ready for Battle. ‘I Don’t Remember the Rifles Being So Heavy’

military.com

Korea’s Army of Senior Citizens Ready for Battle. ‘I Don’t Remember the Rifles Being So Heavy’ | Military.com

  1. Military News

Los Angeles Times

military.com


10. S. Korea pushing to host trilateral summit with U.S., Japan next year



S. Korea pushing to host trilateral summit with U.S., Japan next year | Yonhap News Agency

en.yna.co.kr · by Lee Haye-ah · December 7, 2023

By Lee Haye-ah

SEOUL, Dec. 7 (Yonhap) -- South Korea is pushing to host a trilateral summit with the United States and Japan next year, a senior presidential official said Thursday.

U.S. President Joe Biden was the host of the first standalone trilateral summit involving President Yoon Suk Yeol and Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida at Camp David in August.

Speaking to reporters at the presidential office, the senior official noted the three leaders agreed at the time to try to meet around once a year on whatever occasion.

"We are sounding out their thoughts with the aim of inviting the leaders of Japan and the United States to South Korea for a South Korea-U.S.-Japan summit," the official said.

The three countries have been looking to strengthen their bilateral and trilateral partnerships in the face of growing regional and global challenges, including North Korea's nuclear program and China's rising assertiveness.

On Friday and Saturday, the three countries' national security advisers will meet in Seoul to discuss follow-up measures to agreements produced at the Camp David summit and other meetings between their leaders.


In this file photo, South Korean President Yoon Suk Yeol (L) poses for a photo with U.S. President Joe Biden (C) and Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida as they attend a luncheon following a trilateral summit meeting at the Camp David presidential retreat in Maryland on Aug. 18, 2023. (Pool photo) (Yonhap)

hague@yna.co.kr

(END)

en.yna.co.kr · by Lee Haye-ah · December 7, 2023



11.

My two recommendations:

George Kennan For Our Time, Lee Congdon. 
The Sister: North Korea’s Kim Yo Jong, The Most Dangerous Woman in the World, Sung-Yoon Lee. 



The 2023 War on the Rocks Holiday Reading List - War on the Rocks

warontherocks.com · by WOTR Staff · December 7, 2023

Kerry Anderson

Unwavering: The Wives Who Fought to Ensure No Man Is Left Behind, Taylor Baldwin Kiland and Judy Silverstein Gray. A deeply researched, personal, and fascinating look into the stories of wives of POWs and MIAs during the Vietnam War who tirelessly advocated to bring home their husbands — and the long-term impact they had on the U.S. military and society. One author is a former Navy officer and the other a retired Coast Guard officer, both with experience writing on military topics, while Taylor has personal connections with some of the families highlighted in the book.

Our Women on the Ground: Essays by Arab Women Reporting from the Arab World, Zahra Hankir, ed. This anthology offers vividly written, personal accounts by a diverse group of women with experience reporting from Arab countries. These insightful essays offer unique perspectives on war and violence, as well as sharing the authors’ personal aspirations, experiences, and relationships with family, colleagues, and sources.

Tim Ball

Chip War, Chris Miller. Miller provides an excellent overview of the history of microchips and how they’ve developed into an indispensable part of our everyday lives. As the United States continues to eye China as its primary competitor on the international stage, this book is a helpful explainer on the role of semiconductors in America’s national defense industry, and why Taiwan has emerged as key terrain.

By All Means Available: Memoirs of a Life in Intelligence, Special Operations, and Strategy, Michael Vickers. During a career that spanned five decades, Vickers served as an Army Special Forces noncommissioned officer and officer, a CIA officer, and eventually as the Assistant Secretary of Defense for Special Operations and Low Intensity Conflict. This memoir provides an insider’s perspective on consequential events across the globe, including Vicker’s role as the program officer for the CIA’s operation to arm and finance the mujahideen in Afghanistan in the mid-1980s.

Become a Member

Mike Benitez

Why Air Forces Fail: The Anatomy of Defeat, Robin Higham and Stephen Harris. This book analyzes 13 different failures of various air forces spanning World War I to the Falkland Islands. The historical insights are well-researched, even for obscure failures that most airpower disciples have never heard of, and the lessons are applicable now more than ever.

Military Strategy: A Very Short Introduction, Antulio Echevarria II. This book can be read in an hour or two, but don’t let its diminutive size fool you. The simple way it explains and compares various military strategies makes it a very helpful addition to the toolbox.

Nora Bensahel

Norse Mythology, Neil Gaiman. After I returned from an epic Arctic cruise this summer, a friend lent me this gem of a book to help keep the spirit of my vacation alive. Gaiman turns the sometimes impenetrable prose of these ancient myths into simple and concise stories that beautifully transport you to the land of the gods, trolls, and giants. Don’t rely on the Marvel Cinematic Universe to tell you all about Thor and his adventures; stretch your imagination by reading the original stories for yourself! You may already know how Thor got his hammer, but you’ll also learn why Odin is called the father of the gods, why Loki is such a trickster, where poetry comes from, and how to tell when the end times are upon us.

The Armor of the Light, Ken Follett. Obsessive followers of WOTR reading lists may recall that, in 2018, I mentioned that The Pillars of the Earth was one of my favorite books, and that I recommended the third book in what became known as the Kingsbridge series. Then, in 2020, I recommended the fourth book in the series (which is actually a prequel). I am pleased to report that this latest installment is just as good as the ones that came before it. It jumps ahead to the late 1700s, when the livelihoods of the good people of Kingsbridge are threatened by new weaving technologies, as well as the revolution and Napoleonic Wars that rage in France. This is a perfect tale to enjoy with a mug of hot chocolate on those cold holiday nights.

Claude Berube

Mao’s Army Goes to Sea: The Island Campaigns and the Founding of China’s Navy, Toshi Yoshihara. This book discusses the founding of the Chinese Navy in 1949 and the manpower, institutional, and resource challenges faced by the Chinese Communist Party’s leadership. It also informs the reader on an operational level of the off-shore campaigns waged by the People’s Liberation Army to seize islands. Yoshihara’s mastery of the material and ability to analyze them make this a must-read.

The Gunpowder Age: China, Military Innovation, and the Rise of the West in World History, Tonio Andrade. Although this work has been out for several years, it’s worth an initial or secondary read. Andrade’s scope and explanation dispel many myths about the evolution of weapons and defenses in both the East and West. Andrade captures the reader’s attention from the first chapter and doesn’t let go until the last. The scope of this book is monumental and the discerning reader should have a pen or pencil handy to underline and take notes on the relevance of innovation and technological evolution to contemporary militaries.

Brad Carson

The Coming Wave, Mustafa Suleyman. Generative AI, synthetic biology, and their regulation (or not) are the most pressing issues of the day, and Suleyman, the founder of DeepMind, gives both a survey of these fields and helpful recommendations for their governance.

Number Go Up, Zeke Faux. When it comes to the history of FTX, SBF, and crypto more broadly, this book delivers in a less-ballyhooed but more interesting way than Michael Lewis’ similar book about the same characters.

Nick Danforth

The Oyster Wars of Chesapeake Bay, John Wennersten. With chapters like “Hell on the Half-Shell,” this book gives the impression that the entire history of the United States could be more dramatically told through the harvesting and marketing of the oyster. A perfect gift for anyone interested in seafood, social banditry, or the Mid-Atlantic region.

How to Hide an Empire, Daniel Immerwahr. Whether you agree with the thesis, disagree with the thesis, or have been putting off finishing your own more convoluted take on it for months now, you’ll be hard-pressed to find a more engaging or wide-ranging example of what popular history should be.

Ryan Evans

Planning for Protraction: A Historically Informed Approach to Great-power War and Sino-US Competition,Iskander Rehman. In his new (and first) book, Iskander Rehman adds some much needed historical sensibility to an important debate, demonstrating his eloquent erudition across different periods, subject matters, and specialties.

Collisions: The Origins of the War in Ukraine and the New Global Instability, Michael Kimmage. I haven’t read it yet, but this is the book on the Russo-Ukrainian war that I am most looking forward to. I am confident Michael Kimmage will deliver an essential, original, and elegant analysis when this book is out in March of next year.

Richard Fontaine

The Ibis Trilogy, Amitav Ghosh. Three novels — Sea of PoppiesRiver of Smoke, and Flood of Fire — are set in the years before the First Opium War. The stories connect events in Calcutta, Mauritius, Canton, Hong Kong, and across the Indian Ocean. They are also a linguistic excavation of mixing cultures and people. Good stuff.

Hanoi’s War: An International History of the War for Peace in Vietnam, Lien-Hang T. Nguyen. This is a revelatory history of the Vietnam War from Hanoi’s perspective using North Vietnamese archival sources. If you thought Ho Chi Minh and Vo Nguyen Giap were calling the shots, be prepared to be surprised.

Ulrike Franke

BabelR.F. Kuang. The book starts out as a fantastical story set in the magical Oxford of the British empire. It then develops into a brilliant discussion of colonialization, staging a revolution, and more. A book that will enchant you and make you think at the same time.

Embers, Sándor Márai. I’ve rarely read such an intense book. It is a one-sided discussion of two friends, coming together again after 41 years apart. I recommend reading it without even reading the blurb to avoid spoilers.

Francis Gavin

Global Crisis: War, Climate Change & Catastrophe in the Seventeenth Century, Geoffrey Parker. This book was published over a decade ago. In stunning detail, the renowned historian of early modern Europe explores the interconnected global disasters of war, revolution, plague, and famine that wreaked havoc on the 17th-century world, leading to a significant decrease in the human population. Parker convincingly argues that these disparate catastrophes were related to climate change — a global cooling — and the erratic and counterproductive responses by governments around the world that made the situation worse.

Children of a Modest Star: Planetary Thinking for an Age of Crises, Jonathan Blake and Nils Gilman. Blake and Gilman confront the similar crises of our own time — led by global warming but compounded by other potentially catastrophic and interconnected planetary challenges — and explain why our contemporary institutional and governing practices are woefully ill-suited to the moment. They lay out a bold but plausible conceptual and political agenda to reform and reinvent governance to avoid planetary ruin.

T.X. Hammes

Mastering the Art of Command, Trent Hone. This is a brilliant history of how Adm. Nimitz took the Pacific Fleet from a shattered force that lacked confidence to a confident, flexible organization that learned on the fly. In the midst of the biggest naval campaigns in history, Nimitz had to reorganize not just the combat forces but also support, training, and intelligence organization. It describes his deft handling of personnel assignments as well as dealing with two truly difficult figures — Adm. King and Gen. MacArthur.

The Ottomans: Khans, Caesars, and Caliphs, Marc David Baer. Baer provides deep insights into the enormous, but largely overlooked in the West, impact the Ottomans had on world history. It covers from the 13th century until the early 20th century and filled a critical gap in my knowledge of this remarkable lineage.

Bruce Hoffman

A Peace to End All Peace: Creating the Modern Middle East, 1914–1922, David Fromkin. What accounts for the seemingly endless waves of violence, instability, wars, and conflicts that have plagued the Middle East and especially Israel and Palestine for decades? This book explains how the victorious Western Allies (i.e., Britain and France) carved the region up into spheres of influence and created new boundaries and countries from the Ottoman Empire’s former provinces.

The Plot Against America, Philip Roth. Like last year’s selection, The Oppermans, this novel tells the story of a democracy turned authoritarian: in this case after a charismatic, populist, all-American hero turned fascist is elected president. Although the HBO series derived from it has a far less uplifting and optimistic ending, the book is still worth reading for its depiction of how easily a country can be totally transformed — and antisemitism so readily accepted and legitimized.

Frank Hoffman

Planning for Protraction: A Historically Informed Approach to Great-Power War and Sino–US Competition, Iskander RehmanRehman is no stranger to these pages and he has recently penned a short book that is extremely relevant to today’s security context. In Planning for Protraction, he offers a historically framed understanding of great-power war, its often extended character, its core drivers and characteristics, and an overview of the factors that have often determined a competitor’s strategic effectiveness over the long term. The author, now at John’s Hopkins University, evidences a broad grasp of history drawing back to the classics. Rehman persuasively concludes that victory in such protracted contests depends upon a combination of three core attributes: a state’s military effectiveness and adaptability, its socioeconomic power and resiliency, and its agile alliance management and grand strategy. For those looking for a sophisticated analysis and general policy proposals to mitigate today’s most serious contemporary challenge, the ongoing Sino–U.S. competition, this is it.

In The Arms of the Future: Technology and Close Combat in the Twenty-First Century, Dr. Jack Watling. Watling, of the London-based Royal United Services Institute, has authored a concise but rich examination of future warfare trends. He offers some trenchant observations on the future operating environment in the opening section, and then uses that context to evaluate and design tactical formations to be more effective given changes in the character of conflict. This bottom-up-driven force design is very granular but well-presented and meticulously researched. The proposals are also supported by numerous personal observations from experiments, exercises, and field research in Ukraine, where Watling has distinguished himself with numerous short reports. His comments on urban warfare and armor debates are detailed and surely provocative, standing between the proposed reforms of the late David Johnson and the evolutionary arguments of Dr. Stephen Biddle. This book will appeal to civilian policy leaders questioning land warfare requirements and military combat developers struggling to understand what to keep and what to mold.

Burak Kadercan

How States Think: The Rationality of Foreign Policy, John Mearsheimer and Sebastian Rosato. “States as rational, unitary actors” is one of the most debated themes in international relations theory. In How States Think, the founding father of so-called offensive realism, John Mearsheimer, and his former student, Sebastian Rosato, tackle the question head-on, making a case for the salience of the “rationality assumption” in terms of foreign policy choices. Their arguments may or may not fully convince spectators, but they most certainly deserve their place in the overall discussions about decision-making processes in foreign policy.

Before the West: The Rise and Fall of Eastern World Orders, Ayse Zarakol. Modern international relations theory was born as a Western discipline, produced and consumed mostly in the Western world. The specific Eurocentric origins of the discipline, for decades, has ossified an understanding in which many international relations scholars argued that in order to understand “the international,” we have to study the Western experiences, almost ad nauseum. Building on her previous work, Ayse Zarakol offers a powerful corrective to the aforementioned tendency: To understand “the truly international,” students and spectators of world politics should expand their analytical and empirical attention to non-Western cases, which were hardly “footnotes” in terms of the emergence of the present-day global political order.

Dara Massicot

Master and Margarita, Mikhail Bulgakov. This book toggles seamlessly from Pontius Pilate’s ancient Jerusalem to Stalin’s Moscow. I return to it to understand the darkness in Moscow that emerges periodically.

Memory Makers, Dr. Jade McGlynn. This book discusses how memory and history are manipulated in Russia. Some experiences, like World War II, are a wound that Russian authorities will not allow to heal, and so the manipulated memories fester.

David Maxwell

George Kennan For Our Time, Lee Congdon. George Kennan remains relevant. We should continue to study his life and his lessons, and appreciate his literary skills as he is an exemplar for all national security practitioners. He was not always right but he was a passionate patriot who sought to do what is right for America by helping us to understand our adversaries, most importantly the Soviet Union. We need his critical thinking for today’s national security challenges.

The Sister: North Korea’s Kim Yo Jong, The Most Dangerous Woman in the World, Sung-Yoon Lee. Is the title hyperbole? No, it is not if you understand that what happens on the Korean peninsula will have global effects. As we try to read the tea leaves about regime succession it is imperative that we understand the influence of Kim Yo Jong on the regime. She wields more power than anyone in the north save for her brother. And she is dangerous.

Bryan McGrath

Modern Times: The World from the Twenties to the Nineties, Paul Johnson. I had heard of this much talked-about book for decades, but only recently took the time to read it. My goodness, such sweep and depth! The origins of Leninism, Fascism, Nazi-ism; the rise of the United States and the fall of the British Empire; it is all here in what can only be described as beautiful writing.

Confronting Saddam Hussein: George W. Bush and the Invasion of Iraq, Melvyn P. Leffler. Hard to read this book and cling to the notion that “Bush lied.” Easy to read this book and cling to the notion that the team bungled the implementation, badly.

Erin O’Brien

The Age of the Strongman, Gideon Rachman. This book, released in 2022, feels like an important reflection on our current political moment. Rachman reviews, in easily digestible chapters, the roster of “strongman” leaders that have come to dominate global politics – learning about them in a collective is extremely helpful in understanding the links between their ideologies.

1984, George Orwell. After reading Rachmann’s book, I decided to re-read Orwell’s dystopian 1984. I certainly found it had more resonance now than when I first read it in middle school. I recommend a re-read for those who may have forgotten it. I found myself underlining quite a lot. It felt very relevant in our current moment.

A Very Easy Death, Simone de Beauvoir. This short – but impeccably written – account of de Beauvoir’s mother’s death is a quick but heart-wrenching one. I found it a very important reflection on family and love – could make good reading around the holidays.

Stacie Pettyjohn

Feeding Victory, Jobie Turner. This book highlights an underappreciated aspect of warfare logistics that has risen to the headlines because of the war in Ukraine. The five case studies span from the French and Indian War to Vietnam, and trace the evolution of transportation technologies across domains. Turner’s well-written narrative demonstrates that the combatant that had secure supply lines and could transition between modes of transportation while under attack tended to prevail. As Chris Dougherty highlighted in his CNAS report, Buying Time: Logistics for a New American Way of War, this is an area where the Pentagon needs to make considerable improvements. It could learn from Turner’s historical analysis about how to support distributed operations across the vast expanses of the Pacific Ocean.

Elvis’s Army: Cold War GIs and the Atomic Battlefield, Brian McAllister Linn. This book is less about Elvis Presley and more about the brief period in which the U.S. Army embraced nuclear warfighting. Due to the Army’s lackluster performance in the Korean War and Eisenhower’s New Look strategy, the service’s prestige and resources declined precipitously in the 1950s. In a misguided attempt to be relevant, Chief of Staff Gen. Maxwell Taylor undertook a wholesale reform and made nuclear weapons central to how the Army organized, trained, and planned to fight. Yet the Pentomic Division was a disaster because operational concepts were based on a faulty understanding of nuclear weapons’ effects and many of the tactical nuclear weapons were not reliable or practical. The Army’s nuclear transformation exacerbated recruitment and readiness challenges, leaving the service smaller and less capable than before. A service’s desire for relevance and a central warfighting role against the priority threat has echoes in the discussions today about the Army’s role in the Indo-Pacific. It also highlights the risks of overly focusing on emerging technologies as the key determinant of combat capability.

Mike Pietrucha

Starships’ Mage, Glynn Stewart. A unique blend of science fiction and fantasy where starships exist, but need magic, and thus mages, to go faster than light.

Fire With Fire, Dr. Charles Gannon. Straight, hard sci-fi with a brilliantly conceived future galaxy, full of twists and very, very difficult to put down. For when you catch some winter respiratory disease that puts you in bed for a couple of days.

Christopher Preble

Dying by the Sword: The Militarization of US Foreign Policy, Monica Duffy Toft and Sidita Kushi. With a nearly $1 trillion Pentagon budget, it is easy to see how and why U.S. foreign policy is overmilitarized: Spending drives policy. But the reverse is also true. And our fragile and fractured political system could not sustain such enormous spending if many Americans didn’t actually believe that a massive and active military advances U.S. interests. Toft and Kushi document how we got here and close with a warning of what could happen if we don’t change course.

Underground Empire: How America Weaponized the World Economy, Henry Farrell and Abraham Newman. You might think that all that Pentagon spending creates a military that is the most important tool in the U.S. policy arsenal. Reading Farrell and Newman’s book might change your mind. Alas, the fast-paced narrative might also convince you that that thing which is actually the foundation of US power — a $23 trillion economy — isn’t effectively wielded by anyone, and that attempts to weaponize it could backfire in countless ways.

Iskander Rehman

JFK: Coming of an Age in the American Century, 1917–1959, Fredrik Logevall. One of the finest biographical studies I have ever come across. An epic, eminently readable, and often surprisingly moving examination not only of JFK’s early years, but also of multiple generations of Kennedy strivers and hustlers. The late Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie once quipped that historians all too often fell into two broad categories: They were “either truffle hunters, their noses buried in the details, or parachutists, hanging high in the air and looking for general patterns in the countryside far below them.” In this riveting first tome, Logevall somehow manages to fuse both approaches, and to masterly effect. His granular deep-dive into the Kennedy clan thus serves as a narrative prism through which the reader is catapulted into the dramatic events and roiling passions surrounding the United States’ meteoric rise over the turbulent first half of the 20th century. In short, this is not just the story of a preternaturally talented young Irish-American coming of age, it’s also the tale of an adolescent superpower coming to terms with its raw strength and newfound preponderance in the international system. Like many, I await the forthcoming sequel with bated breath.

Understanding Greek Warfare, Matthew A. Sears. A perfect introduction to Ancient Greek warfare and strategy. Comprehensive, elegantly framed, and clearly written — in an ideal world this book would be assigned reading in any Introduction to Strategic Studies course.

Emma Salisbury

Command: How the Allies Learned to Win the Second World War, Al Murray. Although best known in the United Kingdom for his comedy, Murray shows with this book that he is also a talented historian. Structured around the careers of 10 British and American commanders across multiple theaters — from the famous to the less well-known — Command explores the characters and challenges that each man faced in the crucible of war. Murray achieves this without falling victim to the “great man” theory of history, unusually for books focusing on military leaders, resulting in an engaging and novel approach to a period that still has a lot to teach us.

The Vory: Russia’s Super Mafia, Mark Galeotti. It is impossible to understand modern Russia without appreciating the impact of organized crime, and there is no better place to start than here. Galeotti’s expertise shines through his ever-excellent writing in this history of the Russian version of the mafia, the vory v zakone. Piercing through the commonly overblown legends of vory rituals and blood oaths, Galeotti explores how the blurred lines between crime, law enforcement, and politics that weave throughout their story help us to understand the kleptocracy ruling Russia today.

Jeremy Shapiro

The Wizard of the Kremlin, Guiliano da Empoli. This novel from an Italian writer, originally written in French, tells the story of the rise and corruption of the Vladimir Putin regime. The protagonist, Vadim Baranov, is a thinly veiled fictionalization of Vladislav Surkov, a leading “political technocrat” in the Kremlin through much of Putin’s reign. It is fiction (I think), but it rings eerily true.

Digital Empires: The Global Battle to Regulate Technology, Anu Bradford. The next cold war seems likely to be fought in drab seminar rooms in Switzerland between warring bureaucrats seeking to use regulation to seize national advantages in the technologies and industries of the future. Bradford explains how the United States, China, and the European Union are each advancing a competing vision for the digital economy, while attempting to use regulatory methods to expand their sphere of influence in the digital world.

John Spencer

Gates of Europe: A History of Ukraine, Serhii Plokhy. A detailed history of Ukraine, from Ancient to modern times, to include the development of Russia. The book should be required reading for all decision-makers, academics, or analysts studying the current Russia–Ukraine War.

Son of Hamas: A Gripping Account of Terror, Betrayal, Political Intrigue, and Unthinkable Choices, Moses Hassan Yousef. A unique first-hand account of the development of the Hamas terrorist organization. The author is the son of one of the cofounders of Hamas who turned Israeli informant. He gives a unique view into Hamas as an organization in Gaza, a gang in Israeli prisons, and a military branch controlled by political groups outside Gaza and Israel.

Kori Schake

The Cutting-Off Way: Indigenous Warfare in Eastern North America, 1500–1800, Wayne E. Lee. The absence of studies of the wars against Native populations is a huge chasm in American strategic thought. Yet, the U.S. military fought 943 military actions against Native American tribes between 1768 and 1889, and those wars provided the genesis of much of American military culture. Wayne Lee understands the Native American side of the equation better than any of us and provides an essential window into why they fought the way they did, making clear their strategies and how those married their circumstances.

The Lincoln Highway, Amor Towles. Hard to imagine Towles improving on the exquisite Gentlemen in Moscow, but he does with this beautiful novel of Americana, a fresh and exciting contender for the Great American Novel. This hero is unassuming and worthy, his villains vivid and unique, the action propelling and unpredictable.

Daybreak, Matt Gallagher. We are living through such a renaissance of veteran’s writing, and Matt Gallagher is one of the very best. Daybreak is set in the Russia–Ukraine war, exploring the motivations and fates of Americans who go to fight with Ukraine. It’s an unsparing but empathetic character study — but it’s so much more than that. Reading it brought to mind the masterful work of F. Scott Fitzgerald.

Aaron Stein

Radar Man, Edward Lovick Jr. This is a wonderful — if slightly disjointed — account of the development of stealth from an engineering perspective. It walks someone like me — a laymen — through the development of the technologies to reduce an aircraft’s radar cross section.

The Big Show: The Classical Account of World War II Aerial Combat, Pierre Clostermann. This book is a classic. It is a wonderful walk through history. And a fun read about World War II aerial combat over Europe, from early Scud hunts to dogfights with the Luftwaffe.

Becca Wasser

The Allure of Battle: A History of How Wars Have been Won and Lost, Cathal J. Nolan. This book cuts through the fawning greatness of military genius and the romanticism of decisive battle to highlight the grim realities of long wars and their grinding attritional nature.

DS Maeve Kerrigan Series, Jane Casey. When I’m not reading about war, I like to read about murder. Jane Casey’s DS Maeve Kerrigan Series is the perfect mix: compelling characters, slowly unfolding and complex mysteries, strong writing, and British charm.

Become a Member

Image: Wikimedia Commons

Lists and Contests

warontherocks.com · by WOTR Staff · December 7, 2023









De Oppresso Liber,

David Maxwell

Vice President, Center for Asia Pacific Strategy

Senior Fellow, Global Peace Foundation

Editor, Small Wars Journal

Twitter: @davidmaxwell161

Phone: 202-573-8647

email: david.maxwell161@gmail.com


De Oppresso Liber,
David Maxwell
Vice President, Center for Asia Pacific Strategy
Senior Fellow, Global Peace Foundation
Editor, Small Wars Journal
Twitter: @davidmaxwell161


If you do not read anything else in the 2017 National Security Strategy read this on page 14:

"A democracy is only as resilient as its people. An informed and engaged citizenry is the fundamental requirement for a free and resilient nation. For generations, our society has protected free press, free speech, and free thought. Today, actors such as Russia are using information tools in an attempt to undermine the legitimacy of democracies. Adversaries target media, political processes, financial networks, and personal data. The American public and private sectors must recognize this and work together to defend our way of life. No external threat can be allowed to shake our shared commitment to our values, undermine our system of government, or divide our Nation."
Company Name | Website
Facebook  Twitter  Pinterest  
basicImage