I again lead up to Dummy’s spade with the ♠8, continuing to unblock the suit. West ducks again and I win with the king as East follows with the 10. To clear the suit, I come off Dummy with the ♠4 and play my ♠Q, setting up an entry to Dummy, as West wins her ace, with East pitching the ♣4 (standard discards).
My 2♥ Stayman response and my earlier heart play seem to have convinced West that I have a good heart holding so she came out her ♣2, the play going ♣3, 8, Q (mistakenly, as the 10 was sufficient; if John Dickenson ever gives a seminar on Paying Close Attention, I’m taking it!). I continue the clubs and West plays her ♣J, the lowest of equals, as the ♣Q has been played. I win the ♣A and clear the club suit, leading Dummy’s ♣5 to the ♦2, ♥2 and ♣K.
West is now out of black cards and leads her ♥9. East wins with his ♥A and finally leads a diamond, but it’s too late. I go up with my ace and have the rest, making 10 tricks for a shared top.
Was that clever, or what?
It was an “Or what!” I made 10 tricks thanks to a basic defensive error! Do you see it? It happened at trick 3, when I lead the ♥7 from Dummy. East, holding the ♥A, should have gone up with it immediately. An obvious reason is that he holds the ♥AQ105. What hearts can I possibly hold, if I am leading the suit (though I do know declarers who would lead the suit holding worthless cards; but that type of play is rare.)
But that is not THE reason to play the ♥A. THE reason is that East should go out of his way to win an early trick so that he can return his partner’s suit, especially before his partner has had to use up one of her side entries. So, for instance, if you are Declarer’s RHO holding Kxx in a side suit, and Declarer leads that suit from Dummy at Trick 2 or 3, textbook defense says you should play your K in the hope that partner has the ace and, before she has to play it, you have gotten in and returned her suit. Leading her suit through Declarer may well be all that she needs to set it up.
But in this deal, that is not the layout. East had the ♥A and when I lead a heart from Dummy, he should grab his ♥A and return his partner’s suit. If he had done that, the defenders would have eventually collected 2 diamond tricks, holding me to only 8 tricks and a bad board, which I deserved.
This 2nd hand high play is one of the important exceptions to 2nd hand low. We work hard to train ourselves to play 2nd hand low and now we need to add an exception. Yep, and an important exception at that, if you want to defeat NT contracts, or limit them to the tricks they deserve.
It is easy to make this blunder. I know I have made this type of misplay more than once. I have also seen an opponent with over 10,000 masterpoints make this slip-up, thereby allowing my partner to make her 3N contract, instead of going down.
Therefore, it is not surprising if you do play 2nd hand low in such a situation. Again, we work hard to train ourselves to do so, but in this case you shouldn’t.
Best of luck with this exception.
|