Small dogs are Out-Homing Large Dogs

It is a Doggy-Dog World, and Large Dogs are Losing

The animal welfare nonprofit sector has made significant progress toward ending euthanasia as a means to control the pet population and lowering the number of animals entering shelters each year. After decades of progress, alarms are sounding...the fate of large dogs in American shelters is in crisis. Recent data from Shelter Animals Count, which tracks animal shelter data across the country, noted that dog adoptions were down in 2023 compared to 2022, meaning fewer dogs were adopted nationwide in 2023. The trend is looking bleak for 2024.


There are logical reasons for dog impoundment being up and adoption down, but the story is more complex. It appears that larger dogs are at greater risk compared to smaller dogs. This may be because sometimes people can't bring their animals, especially larger dogs, when transitioning to new housing. Apartment leases often restrict the breed or size of dogs accepted or charge unaffordable monthly surcharges. Some insurance companies deny homeowners insurance to owners with certain breeds or sizes of dogs.


The larger dog crisis has been brewing for over a decade: tiny dogs have taken over the country. Americans’ dog preferences have changed!


Look at the AKC rankings – in the last decade, the French Bulldog reached the top 10 for the first time in more than 100 years. They join the beagle and Yorkshire terrier—the 5th and 6th most popular. 


In the early 2000s, Americans owned mainly medium to large-sized dogs. But ever since then, the number of big and medium-sized dogs snuggling up with us has declined by 1.5 million, while the small dog population has grown by almost 15 million. 

In 2008, for the first time, small dogs were the most popular sized dogs in America, and over 50 percent of U.S. households owned one.

Some think the dramatic shift in dog ownership is due to:



1. Our migration to urban areas. Almost 80 percent of the country now lives in cities and their surrounding areas.

2. With our aging and changes in living situations, smaller dogs are more likely to be accepted into apartments and other group dwellings. 

3. Younger pet owners also prefer smaller dogs -they are more accessible to travel with and care for in vacation environments.

The shift to smaller dogs has enormous ramifications for animal shelters. More than 75% of the dogs entering shelters in America are mid to large size. Suppose too few adopters can adopt them due to housing barriers or too few people want to adopt large dogs; what will the outcome be?


Today, larger dogs, perfectly amazing dogs, are caught in the “length of stay“ "no-win catch-22"


When a dog sits for weeks, regardless of how nice a dog it is, potential adopters think, “he must have an issue,” and skip over him/her. This increases their “length of stay” in a shelter, and each day an animal remains in a shelter environment creates more stress, and they become more barky, nervous, jumpy, etc. All turn-offs to most adopters. 


What is the solution? Change the insurance and housing landscape? Breed large dogs to be smaller? Both are viable; however, stemming the supply of large breed dogs is the most urgent need and practical…over the next several years. 

Give and make fixing fido affordable for someone

The ability to spay or neuter large dogs is also under pressure. It is expensive. The cost of the procedure makes it an “option” many can’t easily afford. But, as a community, we need to figure it out because the clock is ticking, and shelter euthanasia rates for larger dogs are climbing.

Business Partners Help Animals


Rebel was our cause. After being passed by a few times and knowing she needed a special home, she was selected to be Automall’s “billboard” baby.


Her mug was featured in a series of boosted social media posts. One of those posts slid into the feed of the perfect pet parents for Regal. After exchanging information with the team, they drove from Rhode Island to meet Rebel.


It was as if Rebel’s personal Uber arrived, and without a woof or wink back at the shelter team, she jumped inside and was "off" for her new home.


Automall is one of WCHS's outstanding Business "Pawtners." The Business Partner program's four tiers offer companies a variety of ways to help animals along with a large selection of year-long marketing benefits.

"As animal lovers, we take great pride in supporting the Windham County Humane Society and its efforts to make sure all animals find loving homes. We are delighted to see how our contributions make a difference in the lives of so many animals, especially dogs that are often passed over like Rebel. The staff works tirelessly to find a good fit so they can live a happy stress-free life”



Andrea McCauley

Vice President, Brattleboro Automall

If you prefer to send your donation, mail it to:

WCHS, PO Box 397, Brattleboro, VT 05302.

Every life saved begins with you. Thank you for believing in our charity’s ability to make a difference in the life of a helpless or hurt pet.


Thank you,

Maya Richmond

Executive Director