The Hank Center for the Catholic Intellectual Heritage
Nov 2021
From the Director

Dear Friends and Colleagues,

Kind greetings and I hope that all are in good health and spirits.

It has been another set of substantive days at the Hank Center. Our October programming has been focused on the many ways the Catholic Intellectual Tradition lives in and leavens our current moment. Both our Nexus launch event and Fr. Stephen Schloesser's Teilhard Lecture provided our many viewers and listeners with an array of needed observations and ideas-- so many of which describe life in Catholic universities today. On the one hand we witnessed deeply felt concerns about growing secularism, mission drift, hyper-professionalization (in faculty), and signs of decaying hopes (in students); on the other, we also experienced consolation and insight precisely by "leaning-in" to the Catholic Intellectual Tradition. I have been struck yet again by how all of these conversations draw life from the Catholic intellectual heritage as both a content and a method. Catholic habits of mind and heart perform a living tradition, not a static “traditionalism." We draw from the riches of the past to give life to the present-- and, we hope, to the future. The Catholic imagination provides so much in the way of a connective tissue that links theological mystery and culture-- links the deepest desires of our heart and our lives together in the Church and in human community. This imagination continues to serve as a needed resource and inspiration for understanding our lives in God and we are here to help develop it.

The late Monsignor, Lorenzo Albacete, understood the importance of an evolved Catholic imagination better than most. Albacete, a former aerospace researcher turned Roman Catholic priest is the subject of our Zoom Forum this Thursday when we will welcome his beloved friend, Cardinal Seán Patrick O’Malley, OFM, and editors Lisa Lickona and Greg Wolfe for what promises to be a rousing conversation. As his New York Times obituary reported, "Monsignor Albacete’s ministry was sui generis — perhaps the only career path open to a droll, rumpled, chain-smoking theologian-scientist who was unreliable about answering his mail and telephone messages but who could hold his own in a debate with the sharp-witted Christopher Hitchens, the atheist polemicist and journalist." This description only scratches the surface of this singular man and we hope you will join us Thursday evening to hear why. All are welcome and more information below.

Finally, November always moves us to think about the dead. We at LUC have had much sorrow these last months in the loss of beloved colleagues-- Dr. Bren Ortega Murphy and Dr. Michael Kelly earlier this year-- and then Dr. Mark McIntosh in October who we remember below. We lost our dear friend, Dr. James Harrington, who passed away after an tragic accident on October 29th and send our prayers and condolences to his family. We feel the absence of our friends most grievously, even as we know that they are in the embrace our our loving God.

As all of these colleagues were good humored, I include "Notice" by Steve Kowit-- a penetrating poem about death rendered with a light, humane touch.

Be assured of our prayers for all, a Happy Thanksgiving, and,

Warmest Regards,

Dr. Michael P. Murphy
RECOMMENDED READING
In the spirit of cultivating the Catholic intellectual and artistic tradition, CCIH recommends new and notable books several times a year that integrate, interrogate, and celebrate Catholicism in dialogue with the world.

Publisher: The Hank Center for Catholic Intellectual Heritage.

Wait, did we not mention Nexus was already in this newsletter? Yes-- yes we did; but as one of the new initiatives from the Hank Center, it feels appropriate to mention it just one more time to highlight the substantive, thought-provoking work of the authors in this inaugural issue.

Author: Brenna Moore. Publisher: The University of Chicago Press.

Kindred Spirits takes us inside a remarkable network of Catholic historians, theologians, poets, and activists who pushed against both the far-right surge in interwar Europe and the secularizing tendencies of the leftist movements active in the early to mid-twentieth century. With meticulous attention to the complexity of real lives, Brenna Moore explores how this group sought a middle way anchored in “spiritual friendship”—religiously meaningful friendship understood as uniquely capable of facing social and political challenges.

For this group, spiritual friendship was inseparable from resistance to European xenophobia and nationalism, anti-racist activism in the United States, and solidarity with Muslims during the Algerian War. Friendship, they believed, was a key to both divine and human realms, a means of accessing the transcendent while also engaging with our social and political existence. Some of the figures are still well known—philosopher Jacques Maritain, Nobel Prize laureate Gabriela Mistral, influential Islamicist Louis Massignon, poet of the Harlem renaissance Claude McKay—while others have unjustly faded from memory. Much more than an idealized portrait of a remarkable group of Catholic intellectuals from the past, Kindred Spirits is a compelling exploration of both the beauty and flaws of a vibrant social network worth remembering.


Author: Christine Firer Hinze. Publisher: Georgetown University Press.

In this timely book, Christine Firer Hinze looks back at the influential teachings of priest-economist Monsignor John A. Ryan (1869-1945), who supported worker justice and defended a living wage for all Americans in the first half of the twentieth century. Advancing Ryan's efforts to articulate a persuasive plan for social reform, Hinze advocates for an action-oriented livelihood agenda that situates US working families' economic pursuits within a comprehensive commitment to sustainable "radical sufficiency" for all.

Documenting the daily lives and economic struggles of past and present US Catholic working-class families, Hinze explores the larger impulses and patterns—economic, cultural, political, moral, and spiritual—that affect the work these people perform in homes, in communities, and at paid jobs. Their story entwines with the larger history of the American dream and working people's pursuit of a dignified livelihood. Surveying this history with an eye to the dynamics of power and difference, Hinze rethinks Ryan's ethics and Catholic social teaching to develop a new conception of a decent livelihood and its implications for contemporary policy and practice. The result is a critical Catholic economic ethic capable of addressing the situations of workers and families in the interdependent global economy of the twenty-first century.

Radical Sufficiency offers transformative strategies and strategic policy directions for achieving the radical Christian goal of dignified work and a good livelihood for all.

Author: Michael D. Breidenbach. Publisher: Harvard University Press

In colonial America, Catholics were presumed dangerous until proven loyal. Yet Catholics went on to sign the Declaration of Independence and helped to finalize the First Amendment to the Constitution. What explains this remarkable transformation? Michael Breidenbach shows how Catholic leaders emphasized their church’s own traditions—rather than Enlightenment liberalism—to secure the religious liberty that enabled their incorporation in American life.

Catholics responded to charges of disloyalty by denying papal infallibility and the pope’s authority to intervene in civil affairs. Rome staunchly rejected such dissent, but reform-minded Catholics justified their stance by looking to conciliarism, an intellectual tradition rooted in medieval Catholic thought yet compatible with a republican view of temporal independence and church–state separation. Drawing on new archival material, Breidenbach finds that early American Catholic leaders, including Maryland founder Cecil Calvert and members of the prominent Carroll family, relied on the conciliarist tradition to help institute religious toleration, including the Maryland Toleration Act of 1649.

The critical role of Catholics in establishing American church–state separation enjoins us to revise not only our sense of who the American founders were, but also our understanding of the sources of secularism. Church–state separation in America, generally understood as the product of a Protestant-driven Enlightenment, was in key respects derived from Catholic thinking. Our Dear-Bought Liberty therefore offers a dramatic departure from received wisdom, suggesting that religious liberty in America was not bestowed by liberal consensus but partly defined through the ingenuity of a persecuted minority.

Author: Gerald J. Beyer. Publisher: Fordham University Press.

Gerald J. Beyer’s Just Universities discusses ways that U.S. Catholic institutions of higher education have embodied or failed to embody Catholic social teaching in their campus policies and practices. Beyer argues that the corporatization of the university has infected U.S. higher education with hyper-individualistic models and practices that hinder the ability of Catholic institutions to create an environment imbued with bedrock values and principles of Catholic Social Teaching such as respect for human rights, solidarity, and justice. Beyer problematizes corporatized higher education and shows how it has adversely affected efforts at Catholic schools to promote worker justice on campus; equitable admissions; financial aid; retention policies; diversity and inclusion policies that treat people of color, women, and LGBTQ persons as full community members; just investment; and stewardship of resources and the environment.

Author: Susan Kassman Sack. Publisher: The Catholic University of America Press.

The period from 1959–1972 was the crucial years during which the French priest, paleontologist, and writer Pierre Teilhard de Chardin's writing and thought significantly impacted the spiritual thought of the United States. During this time his writings first became available in North America; indeed, over five hundred works concerning him were published in the US during these years.

America's Teilhard: Christ and Hope in the 1960s is a study of the reception of Teilhard in the United States during this period and contributes to an awareness of the thought of this important figure and the impact of his work. Additionally, it further develops an understanding of U.S. Catholicism in all its dimensions during these years, and provides clues as to how it has unfolded over the past several decades. Susan Sack argues that the manner and intensity of the reception of Teilhard's thought happened as it did at this point in history because of the confluence of the then developing social milieu, the disintegration of the immigrant Catholic subculture, and the opening of the church to the world through Vatican II. Additionally, as these social and historical events unfolded within U.S. culture during these years, the way Teilhard was read, and the contributions which his thought provided changed. This book considers his work as a carrier at times for an almost Americanist emphasis upon progress, energy and hope; in other years his teleological understanding of the value of suffering moves to center. Additionally, the stories of numerous persons – scientists, theologians, politicians, and scholars – who became involved in the American Teilhardian effort are detailed.

Finally America's Teilhard notes that in the end, it has been Teilhard's attempts to leap the interstice between the secular and the sacred, particularly in terms of Christology, that remain of value today. It is those which most had, and which continue to have impact upon U.S. Catholic theology.

Editors: Tobin Hansen and María Engracia Robles Robles. Publisher: Georgetown University Press

We are happy to shine a bright light on this this essential new book by our friends-- and Opus Prize finalists-- The Kino Border Initiative. Sr. María Engracia and her colleagues were on campus last week to share stories and inspire students, faculty, and staff to action. KBI was awarded $100,000 for their essential work.

Migrants, refugees, and deportees live through harrowing situations, yet their personal stories are often ignored. While politicians and commentators mischaracterize and demonize, herald border crises, and speculate about who people are and how they live, the actual memories of migrants are rarely shared. In the tradition of oral storytelling, Voices of the Border reproduces the stories migrants have told, offering a window onto both individual and shared experiences of crossing the US―Mexico border.

This collection emerged from interviews conducted by the Kino Border Initiative (KBI), a Jesuit organization that provides humanitarian assistance and advocates for migrants. Based in Nogales, Arizona, and Nogales, Sonora ― twin border cities connected by shared histories, geographies, economies, and cultures ― the editors and their colleagues documented migrants' testimonios to amplify their voices. These personal narratives of lived experiences, presented in the original Spanish with English translations, bring us closer to these individuals' strength, love, and courage in the face of hardship and injustice. Short introductions written by migrant advocates, humanitarian workers, religious leaders, and scholars provide additional context at the beginning of each chapter.

These powerful stories help readers better understand migrants' experiences, as well as the consequences of public policy for their community.

Author: Christopher Beha. Publisher: Tin House Books.

On the day Sam Waxworth arrives in New York to write for the Interviewer, a street-corner preacher declares that the world is coming to an end. A data journalist and recent media celebrity—he correctly forecast every outcome of the 2008 election—Sam knows a few things about predicting the future. But when projection meets reality, life gets complicated.

His first assignment for the Interviewer is a profile of disgraced political columnist Frank Doyle, known to Sam for the sentimental works of baseball lore that first sparked his love of the game. When Sam meets Frank at Citi Field for the Mets’ home opener, he finds himself unexpectedly ushered into Doyle’s crumbling family empire. Kit, the matriarch, lost her investment bank to the financial crisis; Eddie, their son, hasn’t been the same since his second combat tour in Iraq; Eddie’s best friend from childhood, the fantastically successful hedge funder Justin Price, is starting to see cracks in his spotless public image. And then there’s Frank’s daughter, Margo, with whom Sam becomes involved—just as his wife, Lucy, arrives from Wisconsin. While their lives seem inextricable, none of them know how close they are to losing everything, including each other.

Sweeping in scope yet meticulous in its construction, The Index of Self-Destructive Acts is a remarkable family portrait and a masterful evocation of New York City and its institutions. Over the course of a single baseball season, Christopher Beha traces the passing of the torch from the old establishment to the new meritocracy, exploring how each generation’s failure helped land us where we are today. Whether or not the world is ending, Beha’s characters are all headed to apocalypses of their own making.
Contact Us
Loyola University Chicago
Cuneo Hall, Room 428
1032 W. Sheridan Rd. Chicago, IL 60660 Ph: (773) 508-3820

About the Center
The Joan and Bill Hank Center for the Catholic Intellectual Heritage exists to help faculty and students recognize and research Roman Catholic thought and its link to all academic disciplines in the university. It also seeks to convey that thought to other audiences inside and outside Loyola University Chicago.