Supreme Court Rejects Higher Standard of Proof in Overtime Exception Cases
On Jan. 15, 2025, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a decision in E.M.D. Sales Inc. v. Carrera, which decided what evidence an employer needs to show to prove it correctly classified employees as exempt from minimum wage and overtime pay under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). The Supreme Court held that the higher “clear and convincing” evidence standard does not apply to federal wage law and, instead, an employer only needs to meet the “preponderance of evidence” standard. The Court’s ruling addressed a disagreement among federal appeals courts on the issue.
Supreme Court Ruling
The Supreme Court held that the “preponderance of evidence” standard applies when an employer is attempting to prove that it properly classified an employee as exempt under the FLSA’s minimum wage and overtime pay provisions. The Court noted that this was the default standard in civil litigation when the FLSA was enacted in 1938, and the higher standard of proof only applies in limited situations (e.g., when mandated by the U.S. Constitution, when a statute calls for a heightened standard and in situations involving coercive government action). The Court reversed the decision and remanded it to the Court of Appeals to apply the preponderance of evidence standard to decide whether the employees were properly classified as outside sales personnel.
Impact on Employers
The holding in E.M.D. Sales Inc. establishes a consistent standard for FLSA exemption cases. By adopting the preponderance of evidence standard, the Court has eased the burden on employers to establish an FLSA exemption. However, although the Court’s decision makes it easier for employers to prove FLSA exemptions, proper employee classification will remain a compliance burden for employers. Improper classification can result in significant penalties and costly litigation. To mitigate the risk of employee misclassification, covered employers should consider reviewing the FLSA’s duties tests for all exemptions to ensure employees are properly classified, promptly correct any errors and update job descriptions to reflect employees' roles and responsibilities accurately.
Read the entire article HERE
|