Wisconsin Civil Justice Council 

This week, Wisconsin Supreme Court Chief Justice Patience Roggensack delivered the 2019 State of the Judiciary address. Meanwhile, the Supreme Court 2019-20 term is in full swing, with several notable oral arguments coming up and new cases accepted. Also in this edition: PFAS regulation update, multistate actions by Attorney General Josh Kaul, and the latest Court of Appeals decisions.

Please contact R.J. Pirlot  or Paige Scobee  if you have any questions on these or other civil justice matters.

Please feel free to forward this newsletter to others who may benefit from the information it contains.

Chief Justice Highlights Business Court in 2019 State of the Judiciary

On Nov. 6, Wisconsin Supreme Court Chief Justice Patience Roggensack delivered the 2019 State of the Judiciary address. The Chief Justice's remarks highlighted several initiatives in the 2019-21 state budget and the success of Wisconsin's Commercial Docket (a.k.a. Business Court) Pilot project that began in July 2017.
 
Continue reading about the State of the Judiciary.
 
Public Hearing Scheduled for Proposed Wisconsin PFAS Regulations

On Oct. 23, the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources (DNR) Board voted to approve a preliminary public hearing and comment period on three scope statements proposing to regulate PFAS chemicals. PFAS (per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances) are man-made chemicals that are found in many everyday products, including nonstick pans, cleaning products, paints, and firefighting foam. Unnecessarily strict PFAS standards would be costly to Wisconsin industry and would open up the state for frivolous lawsuits and potentially millions of dollars in liability.
 
   
Multi-State Actions by AG Kaul

Since taking office at the beginning of 2019, Wisconsin Attorney General Josh Kaul has announced the state's participation in several multistate actions covering various issues. The actions include comments challenging federal administration proposals, investigations into corporations, and multistate lawsuits and amicus briefs.
 
 
SUPREME COURT
Subtitle
Month Year
Supreme Court Oral Arguments - November 2019

The Wisconsin Supreme Court held oral arguments on Monday, Nov. 4 and will also hold oral arguments on Monday, Nov. 25. Cases of note address issues including recreational immunity, eminent domain and negligent procurement of an insurance policy.
 
 
Supreme Court Holds Oral Arguments in Second Extraordinary Session Challenge

On Oct. 21, the Wisconsin Supreme Court held oral arguments in the second challenge in state courts to the laws passed in the 2018 extraordinary session . This case is one of several challenging the 2018 extraordinary session laws.  Read more about the extraordinary session litigation.
 
 
Supreme Court Accepts New Cases

The Wisconsin Supreme Court recently accepted several new cases, including Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty's challenge to the governor's partial veto power on appropriations bills.
 
Continue reading about this case and other new cases.
 
COURT OF APPEALS
Subtitle
Month Year
Link v. Link (Fair Value & Corporate Misappropriation)

In Link v. Link (2018AP1715), the Court of Appeals District III addressed fair value and corporate misappropriation claims among the owners of Link Snacks and various related entities, which sell and distribute meat products.
 
 
DOR v. Microsoft Corp. (Franchise Tax on Software)

In DOR v. Microsoft Corp. (2018AP2024), the Court of Appeals District IV held that Microsoft's royalties from software sales to manufacturers outside of Wisconsin, whose products are used in Wisconsin, should not be used in calculating Microsoft's Wisconsin tax liability.
 
 
Anderson v. Town of Newbold (Shoreline Zoning & Subdivision Authority)

In Anderson v. Town of Newbold (2018AP547), the Court of Appeals District III held that towns may enact shoreland frontage requirements under their subdivision authority, even though state law prohibits towns from enacting those requirements under their zoning authority.
 
 
Polk Properties, LLC v. Grota Appraisals, LLC (Claim Preclusion in Property Assessment)

In Polk Properties, LLC v. Grota Appraisals, LLC (2018AP2296-FT), the Court of Appeals District II held that claim preclusion barred the plaintiff's negligence and misrepresentation claims against an assessor, after the Supreme Court had previously upheld the assessment challenge in a separate action.
 
 
Sinkler v. American Family Insurance Co. (Cost of Collection)

In Sinkler v. American Family Insurance Co. (2019AP88), the Court of Appeals District III upheld an award of $0 in attorney's fees to a worker's compensation insurer and declined to adopt a rule dividing costs of collection on a pro rata basis - in proportion to their recoveries - between the employee's and the insurer's attorneys in third-party liability actions.
 
 
Brown v. Muskego Norway School District Group Health Plan (Worker's Compensation)

In Brown v. Muskego Norway School District Group Health Plan ( 2018AP1799 ), the Court of Appeals District II held that the plaintiff was in the course of his employment when he was injured in a motorcycle accident; therefore, his health plan excluded coverage because he was eligible for worker's compensation.
 
 
Varsity Tutors LLC v. LIRC (Worker Classification)

In Varsity Tutors LLC v. LIRC ( 2018AP1951 ), the Court of Appeals District I held that a worker was an independent contractor, not an employee, of an online business connecting tutors and students.
 
 

November 7, 2019

Written and compiled by 

Paige Scobee

Hamilton Consulting Group

Wisconsin Civil Justice Council 
10 E. Doty Street 
Suite 500 
Madison, WI 53703
(608) 310-5312

News Clips
Politics
Legislature set for another clash with Tony Evers : Wisconsin State Journal, November 7, 2019.
Former state senator will challenge Grothman : Ripon Commonwealth Press, November 6, 2019.
Tony Evers blasts GOP firing of ag secretary as 'political BS' : Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, November 5, 2019.
Tony Evers administration working to prevent ouster of ag secretary : Wisconsin State Journal, November 5, 2019.
Legal
Senate to consider tougher drunken-driving penalties : Wisconsin Law Journal, November 5, 2019.
Karofsky gains judicial endorsements in 2020 Supreme Court race : Wisconsin Law Journal, November 4, 2019.

More News Clips


Your contribution to the Wisconsin Civil Justice Council will help WCJC promote fairness and equity in Wisconsin's civil justice system, with the ultimate goal of making Wisconsin a better place to work and live.