Trusted by over 100,000 blockchain investors.
INDEPENDENT AND AD-FREE
May 3, 2019
In my new book, I talk about an “aha moment” that came to me as I was listening to a lecture by Chris Burniske. If you don’t know that name, you will.

Burniske is one of the leading thinkers in the field of “Crypto Asset Valuation,” which simply means figuring out how these new digital investments should be priced. (He literally wrote the book on it.)

When I heard Burniske’s talk, the heavens opened up and a choir of angelic beings came down riding golden minotaurs. ( Your mileage may vary.) What he was saying made so much sense. For new assets like bitcoin, we need to find new valuation techniques. Or as I wrote in my notebook:

NEW MONEY NEEDS NEW HONEY

Now Burniske is back with a new paper that outlines his latest thoughts on valuing bitcoin, altcoins, and other digital assets. This is an incredibly important task, as otherwise we have no framework for knowing whether bitcoin (and everything else) is underpriced or overpriced.

Burniske has a brain the size of a planet, so here’s my shot at putting his paper into language that we humble Earthlings can understand.

The Two Buckets of Blockchain

Burniske breaks down the world of blockchain investments into two broad buckets: capital and commodities. 
The key factor is the consensus mechanism. In Burniske’s planet-sized brain, Proof of Stake coins (like Decred) are generally capital, where Proof of Work coins (like bitcoin) are generally commodities. Let’s unpack this a bit.

Proof of Work blockchains use giant mining farms (i.e., huge computing clusters) that perform the calculations to make the blockchain system work: Bitcoin and Ethereum are the two most well-known examples. We might consider these commodities, akin to physical commodities like oil and gold. These blockchains use a tremendous amount of energy in order to produce, or “mine,” a single unit—just like commodities (it’s expensive to dig gold out of the ground).

Proof of Stake blockchains let owners of the altcoin “vote” on the blockchain system, according to how many coins they hold. Instead of consuming vast amounts of electricity, the system works by owners “staking,” or locking up, a certain number of coins: the idea is that those with the most skin in the game are the ones most interested in making the system work correctly. We might consider these coins more like capital, akin to putting your money to work by investing it in a company or a CD.

Here’s the common sense way of thinking about it:

  • If an altcoin needs to be “locked up” in order to get maximum value, it’s a capital coin (just like you need to put traditional capital to work by investing it).
  • If you can just hold the altcoin and get value without doing anything, it’s a commodity coin (just like you could hold value in a commodity like gold).

This is good news. It means that for “commodity coins” like bitcoin, we can estimate a “target price” using traditional economic models.

How Economists Calculate Bitcoin Price

The classic economic model is called the “Equation of Exchange,” which you may remember from :your college econ class:

M x V = P x Q

where
For bitcoin, we know the annual transaction volume (about $3.3 trillion in 2018), and we can estimate the velocity (about 14, thanks to another great Chris Burniske post).

Our starting equation, courtesy of the great economists David Hume, John Stuart Mill, and Irving Fisher:

M x V = P x Q

To solve for M, we can rewrite this as:

M = PQ/V

Which gives us:

M = $3,300,000,000,000 / 14 = $235,714,285,714

In other words, $235 billion is the ideal amount of money needed to “service” all the bitcoin transactions in 2018. If we divide M by the number of bitcoins in circulation (about 17,680,850), we get:

$235,714,285,714 / 17,680,850 = $13,331.62

From there, let’s round it up to $13,333.33 to make it easier to remember. (That’s my contribution.)

There are plenty of assumptions here. You can argue that “real” bitcoin transactions were not $3.3 trillion in 2018; that plenty of this volume is people moving bitcoin in and out of exchanges; that the velocity of 14 is overstated or understated, etc.

That’s why I’ve also included a free Google spreadsheet, which you can use to plug in your own assumptions. ( Download it here in Excel.)

Now we have a number. Bitcoin should currently be valued at $13,333.33. Why? Because economics.

Health, wealth, and happiness,
Sir John Hargrave
Blockchain investor since 2013
Publisher, Bitcoin Market Journal
READER SURVEY: Digital Currency Portfolio
How many different digital currencies are in your portfolio today?

Click here to take this week's survey.
Last Week's Survey Results
Last week, we asked our readers about cryptocurrency mining. Specifically, we asked how much money readers have made in bitcoin and altcoin mining (total value, not including costs). Here's what our readers revealed:
Notable Pieces from Bitcoin Market Journal
How to Make Money in a Blockchain Bear Market

Even in a blockchain bear market, you can make money. Sir John Hargrave reveals how to continue making money from digital assets, even in the midst of a bear market.  Read more here...
Crypto Staking Providers, Rated and Reviewed (+ How They Work)

There’s a new way to make money with your crypto assets, and that is to do nothing at all. That method is based on the growing number of Proof-of-Stake blockchains, where you get paid to hold the tokens of the blockchain. It works best when you take advantage of the law of compounding interest and this BMJ article will give you the low down on the best crypto-staking providers.
Blockchain Hot Topics from the Web


According to a report by Bloomberg trading in Bitcoin (BTC) and Ethereum (ETH) will soon be coming to the 5 million customers of the massive electronic trading platform E-Trade. The report also said that E-Trade is considering adding additional cryptocurrencies in the future, which could make E-Trade a competitor with the likes of Coinbase and Robinhood.

On May 1, Nasdaq began sending real-time XRP (Ripple) "index level information" on its Global Index Data Service (GIDS). A Nasdaq spokesperson has said the new index, called XRP Liquid Index (XRPLX), is "designed to provide a real-time spot or reference rate for the price of 1 XRP, quoted in USD, and based on the most liquid ends of their markets." It's intended to help traders track the value of XRP with greater transparency.

Chris Burniske, co-founder of Placeholder Venture Capital and leading cryptocurrency analyst, explains how the majority of crypto assets are shaping up to be capital assets in nature, whereas many early examples like bitcoin are better characterized as commodities, with a subset poised to become commodity monies. Within the burgeoning capital asset field of crypto, some closely resemble equity, others more closely resemble debt, and others have a bizarre enough mix of capabilities and value streams to be unrecognizable from prior renditions of capital assets.