Wisconsin Civil Justice Council 

Please contact R.J. Pirlot  or Paige Scobee  if you have any questions on these or other civil justice matters.

Please feel free to forward this newsletter to others who may benefit from the information it contains.

Wisconsin Businesses Need COVID-19 Liability Protection

From Bill G. Smith, WCJC President and National Federation of Independent Business-Wisconsin State Director -
 
Across Wisconsin, businesses have shut down and workers gone without paychecks after the state's private sector was largely shuttered to address the COVID-19 crisis. Our economy has taken a severe blow, the worst since the Great Depression. Slowly, parts of Wisconsin's economy are reopening, but the road to recovery will not be easy.
 
For many Wisconsin businesses, a major concern as they reopen is the threat of frivolous lawsuits from potential COVID-19 outbreaks beyond their control, and for which they may not be responsible. Businesses, large and small, are working hard to bring back family supporting jobs and serve their customers. During these unprecedented times, business owners should not be at risk of potentially bankrupting litigation.
 
Governor Evers and the Wisconsin Legislature must work together soon to enact the following four-point agenda to protect Wisconsin businesses from an atmosphere of frivolous lawsuits.
 
 
Wisconsin COVID-19 Response Post-Safer at Home

A few weeks after the Wisconsin Supreme Court invalidated the state's "Safer at Home" emergency order, state and local leaders continue to grapple with the ongoing pandemic and economic recovery. The Department of Health Services (DHS) has declined to promulgate Safer at Home as a statewide rule and instead some local health departments have orders in place. Gov. Tony Evers has also begun allocating federal funds for Wisconsin COVID-19 efforts.
 
 
AG Kaul Submits Briefs on Affordable Care Act, Fuel Efficiency Standards

Wisconsin Attorney General Josh Kaul recently joined multistate coalitions in lawsuits on two important issues: the Affordable Care Act (ACA) and federal fuel efficiency standards.
 
 
SUPREME COURT
Supreme Court Accepts Voter Registration Case

The Wisconsin Supreme Court has accepted the petition for review in Zignego v. Wisconsin Elections Commission, the case surrounding the Wisconsin Elections Commission's decision not to deactivate the registrations of Wisconsin voters who had recently moved.
 
 
Emer's Camper Corral, LLC v. Alderman (Negligent Procurement)

In Emer's Camper Corral, LLC v. Alderman ( 2020 WI 46 ), the Supreme Court held 6-1 that plaintiffs claiming negligent procurement by an insurance agent must establish that the desired policy was both commercially available and that the insured would have qualified for it.
 
 
Correa v. Woodman's Food Market (Safe Place Statute)

In Correa v. Woodman's Food Market ( 2020 WI 43 ), a 6-0 Wisconsin Supreme Court held that plaintiffs in safe place statute cases need not prove the exact moment an unsafe condition existed, as long as they can prove the condition existed for long enough for the defendant to have had constructive notice. In this case, the court said the jury can infer from video evidence that the unsafe condition existed for long enough to give the defendant constructive notice.
 
 
COURT OF APPEALS
Curtiss v. Ellery (Personal Injury)

In Curtiss v. Ellery ( 2019AP1088 ), the Court of Appeals District IV found that the defendant did not establish there were no issues of material fact, so the plaintiff's negligence claim could proceed.
 

Kemper Independence Insurance Co. v. Islami (Insurance Coverage) 

* This case is recommended for publication.
 
In Kemper Independence Insurance Co. v. Islami ( 2019AP488 ), the Court of Appeals District II agreed with an insurer that coverage was not due to an innocent insured when another insured on the policy committed fraud.
 
 
Price v. American International Group, Inc. (Negligence & Safe Place Statute)

In Price v. American International Group, Inc. ( 2019AP57 ), the Court of Appeals District I held that WE Energies was not liable for an injury to an employee of an independent contractor.
 
 

June 8, 2020

Written and compiled by 

Paige Scobee

Hamilton Consulting Group

Wisconsin Civil Justice Council 
10 E. Doty Street 
Suite 500 
Madison, WI 53703
(608) 310-5312

News Clips
Politics
 


Your contribution to the Wisconsin Civil Justice Council will help WCJC promote fairness and equity in Wisconsin's civil justice system, with the ultimate goal of making Wisconsin a better place to work and live.