Is There a Pro-Vaccination Movement?
We've heard from the anti-vaccination side, felt the passion and eagerness of their opinions. But what about the "pro" side? Sure, there are vaccination programs and associations, but is there the energy and zeal that characterizes a
movement?
I asked Erika Edmiston if the "pro" side needed to get more assertive. She responded,
"Regardless of my personal frustration
with anti-vaxxers and their sharing of misinformation, I agree wholeheartedly with the mission stated on the Immunization Ambassador page: 'Passionately Respectful - We believe in immunization 100% and we want to shout it from the mountain tops but we share our passion with consideration and respect for other views and experiences.'
I think that we will get further with people by being respectful and sharing hard science. Stooping to the anti-vaxxers level is just what they want."
I also discussed the "pro" movement with another active Ambassador,
Robert Scheuermann.
Robert is Lab Manager for Huron Perth Healthcare Alliance, overseeing the work of four hospital labs - that's what he calls his "day job," because he's also a lab consultant, working internationally. (T
hat's him in the photo above, visiting one of the countries where he consults.)
While the labs Robert oversees don't administer vaccinations, he says he joined the Immunization Ambassadors because "We see it on the other side - we see the manifestation of the lack of vaccinations."
Among his touching examples of the effects of that lack is when his lab prepares specialized intravenous immunoglobulins (IVIGs) to administer to babies born to a mother with hepatitis B; or, for a pregnant mom exposed to a non-vaccinated child who contracted chicken pox, an IVIG (Varicella prophylaxis) to try to prevent birth defects in her child.
Asked his opinion of the anti-vax people, Robert said,
"My clients include labs in Egypt and in the Caribbean where there is no such movement. The people in those countries are grateful for vaccinations - after all, they have seen the diseases. In those places, the diseases are for real."
He adds, "If the 'anti' people in this country could see the effects of the diseases, they'd come around, and come around quickly."
Why do the "anti" people seem so much more passionate?
Robert says, "The 'pro' side is nicer about it, but part of that is because one side makes the rational case and the other the emotional one."