An improperly formed chaf
The upper and lower right hand corners of the
chaf should be rounded. It is
pasul if either one is squared. If the upper corner is squared and the lower one is rounded, the letter can probably be fixed if a qualified child reads it as a
chaf. This is true even in
tefillin and
mezuzos, where there is a
k'sidron requirement, because the letter conforms to the basic form. A second opinion permits repair even when the bottom corner is squared [and a child reads it correctly]. There is a
machlokes as to whether a
chaf written like this
> -- i.e without a right side -- is kosher.
(
משנת סופרים אות כ וביה"ל ד"ה אם; ביאורים ומוספים דרשו, 1, 3 ו־5)
|