Hilchos Tefilla 108 (page 272)
מסימן קח סעיף ט עד סעיף יא
|
Making Up Regular Tefillos On Special Occasions
Making Up a Weekday Tefilla On Shabbos
Omitting Havdalah from the Makeup Tefilla on Motzai Shabbos
|
Making up regular tefillos on special occasions
If someone missed a regular
tefilla and the makeup occurs at a time that requires a special addition to
Shmoneh Esrei (e.g.
ya'aleh v'yavo or
al hanisim), he should include the addition in the makeup
tefilla. Nevertheless, the
tefilla obligation is still considered fulfilled if it was omitted. If
ya'aleh v'yavo was omitted from the first
tefilla but included in the second one, the makeup
tefilla must be repeated. This is because the first
tefilla (without the addition) is then considered to be the makeup one, and - as we learned earlier--a makeup
tefilla must always succeed the present
tefilla. If, however, he clearly designated the first
tefilla as the present prayer and the second one as the makeup, he has fulfilled the obligation for a makeup.
(
סעיף ט, ס"ק כו-כז; ביאורים ומוספים דרשו, 55 ו־61)
|
Making up weekday tefillos on Shabbos
Someone who missed
mincha on
erev Shabbos should recite the Shabbos
Ma'ariv twice, but he has fulfilled his obligation if the second
tefilla was the weekday version. He does not fulfill his obligation if he recites the weekday
tefilla first, because it is viewed as another example of reciting the makeup before the present
tefilla (see paragraph above). Someone who accepted Shabbos before
davening
Mincha should recite the Shabbos
Ma'ariv prayer twice, but if he recited the weekday
Mincha before nightfall (and before
Ma'ariv), he is
yotzei. The
poskim discuss whether a person in this situation should perform
hataras nedraim (lit. annulment of vows) on his acceptance of Shabbos and recite the regular weekday
Mincha.
(
סעיף ט וס"ק כה; ביאורים ומוספים דרשו, 54)
|
Omitting Havdalah from a makeup tefilla on motzai Shabbos
If someone missed
Mincha on Shabbos, at
Ma'ariv on
motzai Shabbos he should
daven the weekday
Shemoneh Esrei twice. He cannot fulfill his obligation by
davening the Shabbos
Mincha Shemoneh Esrei then. He does not repeat
atah chonantanu in the second
tefilla because only one
havdalah is needed. If he omitted
havdalah from both
tefillos, he has fulfilled his obligation for a makeup
tefilla (even if he ate before
havdalah and is therefore required to repeat the
Ma'ariv
Shemoneh Esrei). If he recited
havdalah only in the second
Shemoneh Esrei, he has not fulfilled his obligation for either
tefilla because he made it evident that he wishes the first one to be the makeup and the second one the current
tefilla. If he clearly indended the first
tefilla to fulfill the current obligation and the second one to be the makeup, he has fulfilled his obligation.
(
סעיף י וס"ק כח, כט ו־לא; ביאורים ומוספים דרשו, 62)
|
|
|
|
|
- An intentionally missed tefilla cannot be made up, but it is permissible to recite a voluntary tefilla instead. The poskim discuss whether, in this case, a voluntary tefilla recited soon after the next required tefilla requires the addition that is usually needed for a voluntary prayer. If it is recited later, it does require an addition.
- If someone missed davening because he fell asleep, or because--despite his intention to daven--he was involved in a project and the zman passed before he realized it, he is considered to have missed davening unintentionally and is permitted to make up the tefilla.
- A missed tefilla can only be made up together with the subsequent required tefilla. Someone who wishes to make up a tefilla after that can recite a voluntary tefilla with an addition.
|
- If a weekday tefilla was recited on Shabbos
- If v'sein tal umatar was omitted from Friday's Mincha
- If ya'aleh v'yavo was inserted in the wrong tefilla
|
|
PLEASE NOTE: The information in this email is for learning purposes only. Please review the Mishna Berura and Biurim U'Musafim before making a halachic decision. Hebrew words are occasionally transliterated to enable a smoother reading of the text. Common Ashkenazi pronunciation is generally used in these cases.
|
|
|
|
|
|