Acceptable Foods for Mishloach Manos
The
mishloach manos foods must be ready to eat, although some
poskim permit raw meat. According to many
poskim, foods that cannot be used alone are not acceptable - i.e. tea leaves, spices, etc. The
poskim discuss whether foods that the recipient cannot eat for health reasons (e.g. he is allergic to them) can be used to fulfill the
mitzva. Water (carbonated water included) is not acceptable.
Reading the Megilah for Others
Someone who already fulfilled his obligation to read the Megilah and is reading on behalf of others is permitted to recite the berachos on their behalf. According to some poskim, when the reading is for an individual it is preferable that the individual recite the berachos. In order to gain the benefit of rov am, someone who will read for individuals should first hear the Megilah in shul or should have in mind not to fulfill his obligation until he hears it later in shul.
|
|
Hilchos Tefilla 107-108 (page 269)
מסעיף ג עד סימן קח סעיף ב
|
Compensating for Missed Tefillos
Compensating for Intentionally Missed Tefillos
Why the Present Tefilla Precedes the Makeup Tefilla
|
Compensating for missed tefillos
Someone who missed a
tefilla-
Shacharis,
Mincha or
Ma'ariv-because of forgetfulness, an error (e.g. he thought he already
davened or he miscalculated the time remaining until the end of the
zman), or an
ones (e.g. he felt ill or became intoxicated, thinking that he would be sober before the end of the
zman) can compensate by reciting the next
tefilla twice. The first recitation fulfills the current obligation and the second one counts as a makeup
tefilla. The
poskim discuss whether the makeup is regarded the same way as a
tefilla that is recited at the correct time. The concept of a
"makeup
tefilla" only applies to
Shemoneh Esrei. There is no compensation for other parts of
davening like
birchos kriyas Shema or
pesukei d'zimra if they are missed. A woman who missed a
tefilla should make it up with the next
tefilla. Although women are not required to
daven
Ma'ariv, if a woman missed that
tefilla she can make it up during the following
Shacharis. Children should be taught to make up missed
tefillos.
(
סימן קח, סעיף א, ס"ק ב, ג ו־ו, ושעה"צ ס"ק א; ביאורים ומוספים דרשו, 2, 3, 4 ו־8)
|
Compensating for intentionally missed tefillos
Generally, there is no replacement for intentionally skipped
tefillos. Nevertheless, someone who chose not to
daven because his mind was not settled or he wasn't able to wash his hands properly (even though it would have been correct to
daven in those circumstances) may compensate for the missed
tefillos. Someone who was involved with a communal project or something similar and was exempt from
davening for the duration of
zman tefilla does not need to make up the missed
tefilla. He should, however, try to recite a voluntary
tefilla-a
tefilla with an addition-to compensate for the missed prayer. If someone who was unsure whether he
davened (and who was therefore obligated to
daven) neglected to do so within the appropriate time, it is questionable whether he must recite a makeup prayer. He is permitted to recite one if he wishes, and does not need to introduce an addition to it.
(
סימן קח, ס"ק א-ב, וביה"ל ד"ה טעה; ביאורים ומוספים דרשו, 1, 5, 7 ו־20)
|
Why the present tefilla precedes the makeup tefilla
The
tefilla that a person is obligated to recite at a given time is recited first, and any makeup
tefilla is recited afterwards. Chazal instituted makeup
tefillos only for people who are already involved in
davening. Someone who intended the first of the two
tefillos to be the makeup must repeat itafter he completes the second
tefilla (with which he intended to fulfill his current obligation). For example, someone who missed
Mincha and
davened
Ma'ariv twice, the first time as
Mincha and the second time as
Ma'ariv, must repeat the
Mincha
Shemoneh Esrei after his
Ma'ariv Shemoneh Esrei. According to some
poskim, this only applies if he somehow demonstrated that the first prayer was the makeup. An example of this would be someone who missed
Mincha on Shabbos afternoon and
davened
Ma'ariv twice, but only included
havdalah the second time. The halacha follows the first opinion, but it is proper to stipulate that if the repetition is not mandatory, it should be counted as a voluntary
tefilla (which does not require an addition). Someone who
davened a makeup
tefilla after his currently required
tefilla but then realized that he must repeat the first
tefilla because of an omission (e.g. he omitted
mashiv haruach) does not need to repeat the makeup
tefilla.
(
סימן קח, ס"ק ז ו־ט; ביאורים ומוספים דרשו, 15)
|
|
|
|
|
- Once someone davens, he may not repeat that tefilla as an obligation. Shemoneh Esrei corresponds to the daily korban Tamid which could be offered only once. It is, however, permissible to voluntarily repeat the tefilla by adding something new, just as it is possible to offer another korban voluntarily.
- Voluntary tefillos are forbidden on Shabbos and Yom Tov just as voluntary korbanos are forbidden on those days. They cannot be recited for Mussaf (on Shabbos, Yom Tov, Rosh Chodesh and Chol Hamoed ), just as a korban Mussaf cannot be brought voluntarily.
- Someone who is unsure whether he davened can repeat the prayer as a voluntary tefilla. Before beginning to daven, he should stipulate that this tefilla should fulfill his obligation if he is obligated or serve as a voluntary tefilla if he is not obligated.
|
- Reciting Ashrei before the makeup tefilla
- Reciting a makeup tefilla after the zman of the present tefilla
|
|
PLEASE NOTE: The information in this email is for learning purposes only. Please review the Mishna Berura and Biurim U'Musafim before making a halachic decision. Hebrew words are occasionally transliterated to enable a smoother reading of the text. Common Ashkenazi pronunciation is generally used in these cases.
|
|
|
|
|
|